Quantum Computation in Brain Microtubules? Decoherence and Biological Feasibility

TL;DR

This paper critically examines the feasibility of quantum computation in brain microtubules, challenging prior decoherence estimates and proposing mechanisms that could sustain quantum coherence relevant to neurophysiology.

Contribution

It revises previous decoherence calculations, demonstrating longer coherence times and proposing biological mechanisms that could maintain quantum states in microtubules.

Findings

Recalculated decoherence time to 10^{-5} - 10^{-4} s after model corrections.

Incoherent metabolic energy can counteract decoherence effects.

Water ordering and actin gelation may extend coherence times to 10^{-2} - 10^{-1} s.

Abstract

The Penrose-Hameroff (`Orch OR') model of quantum computation in brain microtubules has been criticized as regards the issue of environmental decoherence. A recent report by Tegmark finds that microtubules can maintain quantum coherence for only $10^{-13}$ s, far too short to be neurophysiologically relevant. Here, we critically examine the assumptions behind Tegmark's calculation and find that: 1) Tegmark's commentary is not aimed at an existing model in the literature but rather at a hybrid that replaces the superposed protein conformations of the `Orch OR' theory with a soliton in superposition along the microtubule, 2) Tegmark predicts decreasing decoherence times at lower temperature, in direct contradiction of the observed behavior of quantum states, 3) recalculation after correcting Tegmark's equation for differences between his model and the `Orch OR' model (superposition separation, charge vs. dipole, dielectric constant) lengthens the decoherence time to $10^{-5} - 10^{-4}$ s and invalidates a critical assumption of Tegmark's derivation, 4) incoherent metabolic energy supplied to the collective dynamics ordering water in the vicinity of microtubules at a rate exceeding that of decoherence can counter decoherence effects (in the same way that lasers avoid decoherence at room temperature), and 5) phases of actin gelation may enhance the ordering of water around microtubule bundles, further increasing the decoherence-free zone by an order of magnitude and the decoherence time to $10^{-2} - 10^{-1}$ s. These revisions bring microtubule decoherence into a regime in which quantum gravity can interact with neurophysiology.