Event-by-Event Fluctuations in Heavy Ion Collisions and the QCD Critical Point

TL;DR

This paper explores how event-by-event fluctuations in heavy ion collisions can reveal the QCD critical point, focusing on observables like pion multiplicity and momentum, and discusses their potential to identify phase transitions.

Contribution

It introduces methods to detect the QCD critical point through fluctuation analysis and compares thermodynamic predictions with experimental data, highlighting observable nonmonotonic effects.

Findings

Broad agreement between predictions and NA49 data

Nonmonotonic fluctuations near the critical point are observable

Effects of critical fluctuations can be distinguished from background

Abstract

The event-by-event fluctuations of suitably chosen observables in heavy ion collisions at SPS, RHIC and LHC can tell us about the thermodynamic properties of the hadronic system at freeze-out. By studying these fluctuations as a function of varying control parameters, it is possible to learn much about the phase diagram of QCD. As a timely example, we stress the methods by which present experiments at the CERN SPS can locate the second-order critical endpoint of the first-order transition between quark-gluon plasma and hadron matter. Those event-by-event signatures which are characteristic of freeze-out in the vicinity of the critical point will exhibit nonmonotonic dependence on control parameters. We focus on observables constructed from the multiplicity and transverse momenta of charged pions. We first consider how the event-by-event fluctuations of such observables are affected by Bose-Einstein correlations, by resonances which decay after freeze-out and by fluctuations in the transverse flow velocity. We compare our thermodynamic predictions for such noncritical event-by-event fluctuations with NA49 data, finding broad agreement. We then focus on effects due to thermal contact between the observed pions and a heat bath with a given (possibly singular) specific heat, and due to the direct coupling between the critical fluctuations of the sigma field and the observed pions. We also discuss the effect of the pions produced in the decay of sigma particles just above threshold after freeze-out on the inclusive pion spectrum and on multiplicity fluctuations. We estimate the size of these nonmonotonic effects which appear near the critical point, including restrictions imposed by finite size and finite time, and conclude that they should be easily observable.