Thermal excitations of frustated XY spins in two dimensions

TL;DR

This paper introduces a variational approach to study phase transitions in frustrated 2D XY models, emphasizing the coupling of phase and chiral excitations, and validates results with Monte Carlo simulations.

Contribution

It develops a novel variational method that preserves phase-chiral coupling and accurately predicts critical behavior in frustrated XY models.

Findings

Effective long-range, oscillatory interactions between phases in frustrated systems.

Analytical results match Monte Carlo data across all temperatures.

Supports a single phase transition scenario in frustrated XY models.

Abstract

We present a new variational approach to the study of phase transitions in frustrated 2D XY models. In the spirit of Villain's approach for the ferromagnetic case we divide thermal excitations into a low temperature long wavelength part (LW) and a high temperature short wavelength part (SW). In the present work we mainly deal with LW excitations and we explicitly consider the cases of the fully frustrated triangular (FFTXY) and square ( FFSQXY) XY models. The novel aspect of our method is that it preserves the coupling between phase (spin angles) and chiral degrees of freedom. LW fluctuations consist of coupled phase and chiral excitations. As a result, we find that for frustrated systems the effective interactions between phase variables is long range and oscillatory in contrast to the unfrustrated problem. Using Monte Carlo (MC) simulations we show that our analytical calculations produce accurate results at all temperature $T$; this is seen at low $T$ in the spin wave stiffness constant and in the staggered chirality; this is also the case near $T_c$: transitions are driven by the SW part associated with domain walls and vortices, but the coupling between phase and chiral variables is still relevant in the critical region. In that regime our analytical results yield the correct $T$ dependence for bare couplings (given by the LW fluctuations) such as the Coulomb gas temperature $T_{CG}$ of the frustrated XY models . In particular we find that $T_{CG}$ tracks chiral rather than phase fluctuations. Our results provides support for a single phase transition scenario in the FFTXY and FFSQXY models.