Microscopic theories for cubic and tetrahedral superconductors: application to PrOs_4Sb_{12}

TL;DR

This paper investigates weak-coupling theories for unconventional superconductors with cubic and tetrahedral symmetries, exploring multiple transition scenarios and proposing a nearly degenerate singlet state model to explain experimental observations in PrOs_4Sb_{12}.

Contribution

It introduces a weak coupling framework for cubic and tetrahedral superconductors, analyzing symmetry-breaking transitions and proposing a nearly degenerate singlet state model for PrOs_4Sb_{12}.

Findings

Weak coupling theories generally predict only one transition for cubic superconductors.

Multiple transitions in PrOs_4Sb_{12} cannot be explained by weak coupling symmetry-breaking.

A nearly degenerate singlet state model aligns with experimental properties of PrOs_4Sb_{12}.

Abstract

We examine weak-coupling theory for unconventional superconducting states of cubic or tetrahedral symmetry for arbitrary order parameters and Fermi surfaces and identify the stable states in zero applied field. We further examine the possibility of having multiple superconducting transitions arising from the weak breaking of a higher symmetry group to cubic or tetrahedral symmetry. Specifically, we consider two higher symmetry groups. The first is a weak crystal field theory in which the spin-singlet Cooper pairs have an approximate spherical symmetry. The second is a weak spin orbit coupling theory for which spin-triplet Cooper pairs have a cubic orbital symmetry and an approximate spherical spin rotational symmetry. In hexagonal UPt_3, these theories easily give rise to multiple transitions. However, we find that for cubic materials, there is only one case in which two superconducting transitions occur within weak coupling theory. This sequence of transitions does not agree with the observed properties of PrOs_4Sb_{12}. Consequently, we find that to explain two transitions in PrOs_4Sb_{12} using approximate higher symmetry groups requires a strong coupling theory. In view of this, we finally consider a weak coupling theory for which two singlet representations have accidentally nearly degenerate transition temperatures (not due to any approximate symmetries). We provide an example of such a theory that agrees with the observed properties of PrOs_4Sb_{12}.