Jamming of 3D Prolate Granular Materials

TL;DR

This study investigates how the aspect ratio and container size influence the jamming behavior of 3D prolate granular materials, revealing a transition between stick-slip and solid-like states with distinct fluctuation characteristics.

Contribution

It introduces a dynamic phase diagram for prolate granular jamming, linking aspect ratio and container size to different mechanical behaviors and fluctuation spectra.

Findings

Transition region exhibits both solid and stick-slip behavior.

Force fluctuation spectra follow power law tails with exponents -2 and -1.

Packing fraction depends on aspect ratio but is largely independent of container size.

Abstract

We have found that the ability of long thin rods to jam into a solid-like state in response to a local perturbation depends upon both the particle aspect ratio and the container size. The dynamic phase diagram in this parameter space reveals a broad transition region separating granular stick-slip and solid-like behavior. In this transition region the pile displays both solid and stick-slip behavior. We measure the force on a small object pulled through the pile, and find the fluctuation spectra to have power law tails with an exponent characteristic of the region. The exponent varies from $\beta=-2$ in the stick-slip region to $\beta=-1$ in the solid region. These values reflect the different origins -- granular rearrangements vs. dry friction -- of the fluctuations. Finally, the packing fraction shows only a slight dependence on container size, but depends on aspect ratio in a manner predicted by a mean field theory and implies an aspect-ratio independent contact number of $<c > = 5.25 \pm 0.03$.