Velocity profile of granular flows inside silos and hoppers

TL;DR

This study experimentally investigates granular flow inside silos and hoppers, comparing measurements with existing models, revealing limitations of the Kinematic Model, and supporting the Spot Model for particle diffusion.

Contribution

The paper provides high-resolution measurements of granular flow, tests existing models against data, and discusses modifications to improve the understanding of flow dynamics.

Findings

Velocity profiles are smooth, lacking shock-like discontinuities.

The Kinematic Model accurately predicts near-orifice velocities but not far from it.

Diffusion length increases with height and hopper angle, contrary to assumptions.

Abstract

We measure the flow of granular materials inside a quasi-two dimensional silo as it drains and compare the data with some existing models. The particles inside the silo are imaged and tracked with unprecedented resolution in both space and time to obtain their velocity and diffusion properties. The data obtained by varying the orifice width and the hopper angle allows us to thoroughly test models of gravity driven flows inside these geometries. All of our measured velocity profiles are smooth and free of the shock-like discontinuities ("rupture zones") predicted by critical state soil mechanics. On the other hand, we find that the simple Kinematic Model accurately captures the mean velocity profile near the orifice, although it fails to describe the rapid transition to plug flow far away from the orifice. The measured diffusion length $b$, the only free parameter in the model, is not constant as usually assumed, but increases with both the height above the orifice and the angle of the hopper. We discuss improvements to the model to account for the differences. From our data, we also directly measure the diffusion of the particles and find it to be significantly less than predicted by the Void Model, which provides the classical microscopic derivation of the Kinematic Model in terms of diffusing voids in the packing. However, the experimental data is consistent with the recently proposed Spot Model, based on a simple mechanism for cooperative diffusion. Finally, we discuss the flow rate as a function of the orifice width and hopper angles. We find that the flow rate scales with the orifice size to the power of 1.5, consistent with dimensional analysis. Interestingly, the flow rate increases when the funnel angle is increased.