Competition and cooperation:aspects of dynamics in sandpiles

TL;DR

This paper reviews granular dynamics focusing on cooperation and competition among grains, exploring their effects on structures like stable bridges, relaxation processes, and compaction, with insights into shape effects and entropic landscapes.

Contribution

It introduces a comprehensive review of cooperative and competitive processes in granular materials, including a novel random graph model for compaction and analysis of shape effects near jamming.

Findings

Stable bridges exhibit specific geometrical characteristics.

Distinct fast and slow regimes in compaction dynamics.

Surface intermittency observed under low-intensity shaking.

Abstract

In this article, we review some of our approaches to granular dynamics, now well known to consist of both fast and slow relaxational processes. In the first case, grains typically compete with each other, while in the second, they cooperate. A typical result of {\it cooperation} is the formation of stable bridges, signatures of spatiotemporal inhomogeneities; we review their geometrical characteristics and compare theoretical results with those of independent simulations. {\it Cooperative} excitations due to local density fluctuations are also responsible for relaxation at the angle of repose; the {\it competition} between these fluctuations and external driving forces, can, on the other hand, result in a (rare) collapse of the sandpile to the horizontal. Both these features are present in a theory reviewed here. An arena where the effects of cooperation versus competition are felt most keenly is granular compaction; we review here a random graph model, where three-spin interactions are used to model compaction under tapping. The compaction curve shows distinct regions where 'fast' and 'slow' dynamics apply, separated by what we have called the {\it single-particle relaxation threshold}. In the final section of this paper, we explore the effect of shape -- jagged vs. regular -- on the compaction of packings near their jamming limit. One of our major results is an entropic landscape that, while microscopically rough, manifests {\it Edwards' flatness} at a macroscopic level. Another major result is that of surface intermittency under low-intensity shaking.