Screening of Coulomb interactions in transition metals

TL;DR

This paper compares the constraint-LDA and GW methods for calculating screened Coulomb interactions in transition metals, highlighting their differences and proposing a combined approach to include energy-dependent screening effects.

Contribution

It introduces a hybrid method that combines constraint-LDA and RPA to better account for energy-dependent screening in transition metals.

Findings

Constraint-LDA and GW are complementary methods for screening calculations.

The proposed hybrid approach captures energy-dependent screening effects.

The method improves the accuracy of Coulomb interaction estimates in transition metals.

Abstract

We discuss different methods of calculation of the screened Coulomb interaction $U$ in transition metals and compare the constraint local-density approximation (LDA) with the GW approach. We clarify that they offer complementary methods of treating the screening and should serve for different purposes. In the GW method, the renormalization of bare on-site Coulomb interactions between 3d electrons occurs mainly through the screening by the same 3d electrons, treated in the random phase approximation (RPA). The basic difference of the constraint-LDA method is that it deals with the neutral processes, where the Coulomb interactions are additionally screened by the ``excited'' electron, since it continues to stay in the system. This is the main channel of screening by the itinerant ($4sp$) electrons, which is especially strong in the case of transition metals and missing in the GW approach, although the details of this screening may be affected by additional approximations, which typically supplement these two methods. The major drawback of the conventional constraint-LDA method is that it does not allow to treat the energy-dependence of $U$. We propose a promising approximation based on the combination of these two methods. First, we take into account the screening of Coulomb interactions in the 3d-electron-line bands located near the Fermi level by the states from the subspace being orthogonal to these bands, using the constraint-LDA methods. The obtained interactions are further renormalized within the bands near the Fermi level in RPA. This allows the energy-dependent screening by electrons near the Fermi level including the same 3d electrons.