Comments on "Anomalous-Filling-Factor-Dependent Nuclear Spin Polarization in a 2D Electron System: Quantum Hall Effect" by J.H.Smet, K. von Klitzing et al, Phys. Rev. Lett. 92, 086802(2004)

TL;DR

This paper critiques a previous study on nuclear spin polarization in quantum Hall systems, claiming misrepresentation of references, theories, and credit, and emphasizing the importance of proper citation and acknowledgment of correct theories.

Contribution

It highlights the misattribution and neglect of correct theoretical references in prior research on nuclear spin polarization in quantum Hall effects.

Findings

Incorrect references and theories cited in the original paper

Misattribution of discoveries and credit

Neglect of the correct theoretical framework

Abstract

We find that the nuclear-spin polarization has not been treated correctly. The references given are those of wrong papers. The credits assigned for discoveries are also not correct. Incorrect theories have been cited. The reference to the correct theory has been neglected. Because there are lots of good people, so they do not want to give reference to my papers even though they have not solved the problem of quantum Hall effect and we have.