Free energy and configurational entropy of liquid silica: fragile-to-strong crossover and polyamorphism

TL;DR

This study uses molecular dynamics simulations to connect the fragile-to-strong crossover in liquid silica to changes in its potential energy landscape and configurational entropy, providing insights into polyamorphism and the Kauzmann paradox.

Contribution

It demonstrates how the fragile-to-strong transition in liquid silica relates to PES properties and entropy changes, offering a thermodynamic perspective on polyamorphism.

Findings

FSC linked to inflection in inherent structure energy with temperature

Configurational entropy behavior suggests avoidance of Kauzmann paradox

PES changes related to potential liquid-liquid phase transition

Abstract

Recent molecular dynamics (MD) simulations of liquid silica, using the ``BKS'' model [Van Beest, Kramer and van Santen, Phys. Rev. Lett. {\bf 64}, 1955 (1990)], have demonstrated that the liquid undergoes a dynamical crossover from super-Arrhenius, or ``fragile'' behavior, to Arrhenius, or ``strong'' behavior, as temperature $T$ is decreased. From extensive MD simulations, we show that this fragile-to-strong crossover (FSC) can be connected to changes in the properties of the potential energy landscape, or surface (PES), of the liquid. To achieve this, we use thermodynamic integration to evaluate the absolute free energy of the liquid over a wide range of density and $T$. We use this free energy data, along with the concept of ``inherent structures'' of the PES, to evaluate the absolute configurational entropy $S_c$ of the liquid. We find that the temperature dependence of the diffusion coefficient and of $S_c$ are consistent with the prediction of Adam and Gibbs, including in the region where we observe the FSC to occur. We find that the FSC is related to a change in the properties of the PES explored by the liquid, specifically an inflection in the $T$ dependence of the average inherent structure energy. In addition, we find that the high $T$ behavior of $S_c$ suggests that the liquid entropy might approach zero at finite $T$, behavior associated with the so-called Kauzmann paradox. However, we find that the change in the PES that underlies the FSC is associated with a change in the $T$ dependence of $S_c$ that elucidates how the Kauzmann paradox is avoided in this system. Finally, we also explore the relation of the observed PES changes to the recently discussed possibility that BKS silica exhibits a liquid-liquid phase transition, a behavior that has been proposed to underlie the observed polyamorphism of amorphous solid silica.