Comment on "Conservative force fields in nonextensive kinetic theory."

TL;DR

This paper critiques a previous work that improperly applied Maxwell-Boltzmann theory to an unrealistic model, arguing that the claimed problem and its proposed solution are not scientifically meaningful.

Contribution

It provides a critical commentary on the misuse of nonextensive kinetic theory in a specific context, emphasizing the importance of scientific rigor.

Findings

The original application was based on an unrealistic model.

The claimed problem does not exist in a meaningful physical context.

The critique highlights the importance of proper scientific standards.

Abstract

We discuss an improper application of the Maxwell-Boltzmann theory to a very unrealistic model. The authors of the original paper claim that a generalized theory would solve a problem that really does not exists. This Comment was submited to Physica A and was not accepted as it is. Although tecnically correct, we mantain ours view that such kind of "elementary exercises" would not deserve publication in any serious journal as Physica A.