Comment on "The nature of slow dynamics in a minimal model of frustration limited domains" by P. L. Geissler and D. R. Reichman, cond-mat/0304254

TL;DR

This paper critiques recent Monte Carlo simulations, arguing they do not conclusively support or refute the existence of a self-generated glass transition in the Brazovskii model.

Contribution

It provides a critical analysis of previous simulation results, clarifying their limitations regarding the Brazovskii model's glass transition.

Findings

Monte Carlo results are inconclusive about the glass transition

The authors' model remains plausible despite previous simulations

Further research needed to confirm the transition

Abstract

We argue that the recent Monte Carlo calculations by Geissler and Reichman (cond-mat/0304254) are not conclusive in ruling out or supporting the self-generated glass transition of the Brazovskii model proposed by us.