The US 2000-2002 Market Descent: How Much Longer and Deeper?

TL;DR

This paper analyzes the US S&P 500's 2000-2002 decline, revealing herding behavior and log-periodic patterns, and predicts future market movements based on anti-bubble theory, highlighting similarities with the Japanese Nikkei index's past behavior.

Contribution

It demonstrates the existence of herding signatures in the S&P 500's decline using log-periodic analysis and extends anti-bubble theory to predict future market evolution.

Findings

Identification of log-periodic signatures in the S&P 500 decline

Three scenarios for future market evolution until 2004

Similarities between US and Japanese market downturns

Abstract

A remarkable similarity in the behavior of the US S&P500 index from 1996 to August 2002 and of the Japanese Nikkei index from 1985 to 1992 (11 years shift) is presented, with particular emphasis on the structure of the bearish phases. Extending a previous analysis of Johansen and Sornette [1999, 2000] on the Nikkei index ``anti-bubble'' based on a theory of cooperative herding and imitation working both in bullish as well as in bearish regimes, we demonstrate the existence of a clear signature of herding in the decay of the S&P500 index since August 2000 with high statistical significance, in the form of strong log-periodic components. We offer a detailed analysis of what could be the future evolution of the S&P500 index over the next two years, according to three versions of the theory: we expect an overall continuation of the bearish phase, punctuated by local rallies; we predict an overall increasing market until the end of the year 2002 or at the beginning of 2003 (first quarter); we predict a strong following descent (with maybe one or two severe up and downs in the middle) which stops during the first semester of 2004. After this strong minimum, the market is expected to recover. Beyond, our prediction horizon is made fuzzy by the possible effect of additional nonlinear collective effects and of a real departure from the anti-bubble regime. The similarities between the two stock market indices may reflect deeper similarities between the fundamentals of two economies which both went through over-valuation with strong speculative phases preceding the transition to bearish phases characterized by a surprising number of bad surprises (bad loans for Japan and accounting frauds for the US) sapping investors' confidence.