Two-dimensional Packing in Prolate Granular Materials

TL;DR

This study examines the packing behavior of highly elongated granular particles in two dimensions, comparing experimental results with simulations to understand packing density, particle orientation, and void distributions.

Contribution

It provides new insights into the packing structure of prolate particles, including correlation lengths, void size distributions, and scaling laws at large aspect ratios, combining experiments and Monte-Carlo simulations.

Findings

Average packing fraction is approximately 0.68 for aspect ratio 12.

Orientational correlation length is about two particle lengths.

Void size distribution follows a power law with exponent -2.43.

Abstract

We investigate the two-dimensional packing of extremely prolate (aspect ratio $\alpha=L/D>10$) granular materials, comparing experiments with Monte-Carlo simulations. The average packing fraction of particles with aspect ratio $\alpha=12$ is $0.68\pm0.03$. We quantify the orientational correlation of particles and find a correlation length of two particle lengths. The functional form of the decay of orientational correlation is the same in both experiments and simulations spanning three orders of magnitude in aspect ratio. This function decays over a distance of two particle lengths. It is possible to identify voids in the pile with sizes ranging over two orders of magnitude. The experimental void distribution function is a power law with exponent $-\beta=-2.43\pm0.08$. Void distributions in simulated piles do not decay as a power law, but do show a broad tail. We extend the simulation to investigate the scaling at very large aspect ratios. A geometric argument predicts the pile number density to scale as $\alpha^{-2}$. Simulations do indeed scale this way, but particle alignment complicates the picture, and the actual number densities are quite a bit larger than predicted.