The distance to the Pleiades: Main sequence fitting in the near infrared

TL;DR

This study uses near-infrared main sequence fitting to accurately determine the Pleiades' distance, confirming previous non-Hipparcos measurements and highlighting issues with optical colours and Hipparcos parallax errors.

Contribution

The paper demonstrates that infrared colours provide consistent distance estimates for the Pleiades, resolving discrepancies caused by optical colour anomalies and Hipparcos parallax errors.

Findings

Infrared main sequence fitting yields a distance of approximately 134 pc.

Optical (B-V) colours are anomalous for the lower main sequence in the Pleiades.

Hipparcos parallax measurements are likely in error by about 10%.

Abstract

Hipparcos parallax measurements of stars in the Pleiades notoriously result in a cluster distance of 118 pc; ~10% shorter than the `classical' results of MS-fitting. In an earlier paper we developed a purely empirical MS-fitting method to address this problem, which produced conflicting results between the (B-V) and (V-I) colour indices, indicating that the cluster's photometric metallicity is substantially lower than its (~solar) spectroscopic metallicity. We were able to reconcile the discrepancy by assuming [Fe/H]=-0.4 (as indicated from (B-V)/(V-I) colour-colour plots), and the distance moduli obtained from the 2 indices were in agreement with the Hipparcos result, within the 1sig errors. With the release of the 2MASS All Sky Catalogue, we now apply our MS-fitting method to the Pleiades using the infrared colours, in order to test the plausibility of our earlier result. Fitting in the V/(V-K) and K/(J-K) colour planes, we find that assuming a subsolar metallicity does not produce distances in agreement with the (B-V) and (V-I) results. However the infrared plus (V-I) distances are in mutual agreement when adopting the spectroscopic metallicity. By considering only stars with Mv<=6, the infrared and optical colour indices all yield consistent distances using the spectroscopic [Fe/H]. The concordant distances thus obtained from the (B-V), (V-I), (V-K) and (J-K) indices yield a mean of 133.8+/-3 pc, in excellent agreement with the pre-Hipparcos MS-fitting results, and the most recent determinations from other methods. We conclude that there are two distinct issues affecting the Pleiades: the Hipparcos parallax is in error by ~10%, as previously claimed; the (B-V) colours of the lower MS are anomalous, and we caution against their use for MS-fitting to the Pleiades and similarly young open clusters. (Abridged)