Physical limits to the validity of synthesis models: The Lowest Luminosity Limit

TL;DR

This paper introduces a Lowest Luminosity Limit (LLL) for synthesis models, establishing when such models are valid based on cluster luminosity and mass, and explores implications for observational surveys and globular clusters.

Contribution

It defines the LLL for synthesis models, providing a criterion for their validity and analyzing the impact of sampling effects on cluster color distributions.

Findings

The LLL is independent of the IMF and nearly independent of star formation history.

Clusters with mass near Mmin show significant dispersion in photometric colors.

Sampling effects influence observed cluster colors, especially near the LLL.

Abstract

(abriged) In this paper we establish a Lowest Luminosity Limit (LLL) for the use of synthesis codes. The limit is defined by the following statement: The total luminosity of the cluster modeled must be larger than the individual contribution of any of the stars included in the assumed isochrones. This limit is independent of the assumptions on the IMF and almost independent on the star formation history. We have obtained the LLL for a wide range of ages (5 Myr to 20 Gyr) and metallicities (Z=0 to Z=0.019) from Girardi et al. (2002) isochrones. Using the LLL and the results of evolutionary synthesis models we have also obtained the minimal cluster mass, Mmin, for which the results of synthesis models may suffer from a severe bias in the computation of colors. We show that the results of synthesis models for clusters with mass equal to Mmin have a relative dispersion about or larger than 32% (i.e. a dispersion of 0.35 mag) in the corresponding photometric bands. This effect is more important for near infrared bands (except in the case where Asymptotic Giant Branch stars dominate the luminosity in optical bands). In particular, Mmin takes values between 10^4 and 10^5 Mo for the K band. From the observational point of view, we show that in surveys that reach luminosities near the LLL, the color distributions will be skewed toward the color with lower effective sources (toward the red in general), and that the skewness is a signature of the distribution of initial cluster masses in the survey. We also apply the LLL to Globular Clusters showing that sampling effects are relevant in these clusters and that they can explain (at least partially) the bias of the observed colors with respect to the predictions of synthesis models.