# STARR-seq identifies active, chromatin-masked, and dormant enhancers in pluripotent mouse embryonic stem cells

**Authors:** Tianran Peng, Yanan Zhai, Yaser Atlasi, Menno ter Huurne, Hendrik Marks, Hendrik G. Stunnenberg, Wout Megchelenbrink

PMC · DOI: 10.1186/s13059-020-02156-3 · Genome Biology · 2020-09-10

## TL;DR

This study uses STARR-seq to identify enhancers in mouse embryonic stem cells, revealing active, masked, and dormant enhancers that influence cell identity and differentiation.

## Contribution

The study introduces STARR-seq as a method to uncover enhancer activity in mESCs, revealing enhancers that are masked or dormant under standard chromatin assays.

## Key findings

- Active STARR-seq loci show only modest overlap with enhancer locations identified by ChIP-seq.
- ZIC3-bound loci with STARR-seq activity in SL-ESCs are revealed, and Zic3 knockout increases endodermal differentiation.
- Dormant p53-bound enhancers gain activity under specific conditions like Nocodazol treatment or during reprogramming.

## Abstract

Enhancers are distal regulators of gene expression that shape cell identity and control cell fate transitions. In mouse embryonic stem cells (mESCs), the pluripotency network is maintained by the function of a complex network of enhancers, that are drastically altered upon differentiation. Genome-wide chromatin accessibility and histone modification assays are commonly used as a proxy for identifying putative enhancers and for describing their activity levels and dynamics.

Here, we applied STARR-seq, a genome-wide plasmid-based assay, as a read-out for the enhancer landscape in “ground-state” (2i+LIF; 2iL) and “metastable” (serum+LIF; SL) mESCs. This analysis reveals that active STARR-seq loci show modest overlap with enhancer locations derived from peak calling of ChIP-seq libraries for common enhancer marks. We unveil ZIC3-bound loci with significant STARR-seq activity in SL-ESCs. Knock-out of Zic3 removes STARR-seq activity only in SL-ESCs and increases their propensity to differentiate towards the endodermal fate. STARR-seq also reveals enhancers that are not accessible, masked by a repressive chromatin signature. We describe a class of dormant, p53 bound enhancers that gain H3K27ac under specific conditions, such as after treatment with Nocodazol, or transiently during reprogramming from fibroblasts to pluripotency.

In conclusion, loci identified as active by STARR-seq often overlap with those identified by chromatin accessibility and active epigenetic marking, yet a significant fraction is epigenetically repressed or display condition-specific enhancer activity.

## Linked entities

- **Genes:** ZIC3 (Zic family zinc finger 3) [NCBI Gene 7547], TP53 (tumor protein p53) [NCBI Gene 7157]
- **Chemicals:** Nocodazol (PubChem CID 4122)
- **Species:** Mus musculus (taxon 10090)

## Full-text entities

- **Genes:** Dnmt1 (DNA methyltransferase 1) [NCBI Gene 13433] {aka Cxxc9, Dnmt, Dnmt1o, MCMT, MTase, Met-1}, Apk (acid phosphatase, kidney) [NCBI Gene 109950], TBX20 (T-box transcription factor 20) [NCBI Gene 57057] {aka ASD4}, Klf2 (Kruppel-like transcription factor 2 (lung)) [NCBI Gene 16598] {aka Lklf}, Tcf7l1 (transcription factor 7 like 1 (T cell specific, HMG box)) [NCBI Gene 21415] {aka Tcf-3, Tcf3, bHLHb21}, Pou5f1 (POU domain, class 5, transcription factor 1) [NCBI Gene 18999] {aka NF-A3, Oct-3, Oct-3/4, Oct-4, Oct3, Oct3/4}, Tff2 (trefoil factor 2 (spasmolytic protein 1)) [NCBI Gene 21785] {aka SP, mSP}, Zfp281 (zinc finger protein 281) [NCBI Gene 226442] {aka Znf281}, Trp53-ps (transformation related protein 53, pseudogene) [NCBI Gene 22060], Zic3 (zinc finger protein of the cerebellum 3) [NCBI Gene 22773] {aka Bn, Ka}, Prdm14 (PR domain containing 14) [NCBI Gene 383491], Dab2 (disabled 2, mitogen-responsive phosphoprotein) [NCBI Gene 13132] {aka 5730435J12Rik, D15Wsu122e, D630005B22Rik, Doc-2, Doc2, p96}, FOXP1 (forkhead box P1) [NCBI Gene 27086] {aka 12CC4, HSPC215, MFH, QRF1, hFKH1B}, Esrrb (estrogen related receptor, beta) [NCBI Gene 26380] {aka Err2, Errb, Estrrb, Nr3b2}, Itpr3 (inositol 1,4,5-triphosphate receptor 3) [NCBI Gene 16440] {aka IP3R 3, IP3R-3, Ip3r3, Itpr-3, tf}, Tcf3 (transcription factor 3) [NCBI Gene 21423] {aka A1, ALF2, E12, E12/E47, E2A, E47}, Klf4 (Kruppel-like transcription factor 4 (gut)) [NCBI Gene 16600] {aka EZF, Gklf, Zie}, Marcksl1 (MARCKS-like 1) [NCBI Gene 17357] {aka D4Bc1, F52, MacMARCKS, Macs2, Macs3, Mlp}, Zic2 (zinc finger protein of the cerebellum 2) [NCBI Gene 22772] {aka HPE5, Ku}, Ep300 (E1A binding protein p300) [NCBI Gene 328572] {aka A430090G16, A730011L11, KAT3B, p300, p300 HAT}, Sox17 (SRY (sex determining region Y)-box 17) [NCBI Gene 20671], Scpro1 (stem cell proliferation 1) [NCBI Gene 114743] {aka Scp1}, Gata4 (GATA binding protein 4) [NCBI Gene 14463] {aka Gata-4}, JUN (Jun proto-oncogene, AP-1 transcription factor subunit) [NCBI Gene 3725] {aka AP-1, AP1, c-Jun, cJUN, p39}, Otx2 (orthodenticle homeobox 2) [NCBI Gene 18424] {aka E130306E05Rik}, NRF1 (nuclear respiratory factor 1) [NCBI Gene 4899] {aka ALPHA-PAL}, Nrf1 (nuclear respiratory factor 1) [NCBI Gene 18181] {aka D6Ertd415e}, Skil (SKI-like proto-oncogene) [NCBI Gene 20482] {aka Skir, SnoN, sno}, Scgb1b27 (secretoglobin, family 1B, member 27) [NCBI Gene 11354] {aka Abp, Abpa, Abpa27, Sal-1, Tcp}, EP300 (EP300 lysine acetyltransferase) [NCBI Gene 2033] {aka KAT3B, MKHK2, RSTS2, p300}, Zic1 (zinc finger protein of the cerebellum 1) [NCBI Gene 22771] {aka ZIC, ZNF201}, Lif (leukemia inhibitory factor) [NCBI Gene 16878], TRIM28 (tripartite motif containing 28) [NCBI Gene 10155] {aka KAP1, PPP1R157, RNF96, TF1B, TIF1B, TIF1beta}, Gbx2 (gastrulation brain homeobox 2) [NCBI Gene 14472] {aka D130058E05Rik, Gbx-2, MMoxA, Stra7}, Gsk3b (glycogen synthase kinase 3 beta) [NCBI Gene 56637] {aka 7330414F15Rik, 8430431H08Rik, GSK-3, GSK-3beta, GSK3}, Sox2 (SRY (sex determining region Y)-box 2) [NCBI Gene 20674] {aka Sox-2, lcc, ysb}, LIF (LIF interleukin 6 family cytokine) [NCBI Gene 3976] {aka CDF, DIA, HILDA, MLPLI}, TP53 (tumor protein p53) [NCBI Gene 7157] {aka BCC7, BMFS5, LFS1, P53, TRP53}, Nanog (Nanog homeobox) [NCBI Gene 71950] {aka 2410002E02Rik, ENK, Stm1, ecat4}, Mdk (midkine) [NCBI Gene 17242] {aka MK, Mek}, Trp53 (transformation related protein 53) [NCBI Gene 22059] {aka Tp53, bbl, bfy, bhy, p44, p53}, Hgs (HGF-regulated tyrosine kinase substrate) [NCBI Gene 15239] {aka Hgr, Hrs, ZFYVE8, tn}, Cubn (cubilin) [NCBI Gene 65969] {aka D2Wsu88e}, YY1 (YY1 transcription factor) [NCBI Gene 7528] {aka DELTA, GADEVS, INO80S, NF-E1, UCRBP, YIN-YANG-1}, Lefty1 (left right determination factor 1) [NCBI Gene 13590] {aka Ebaf, Leftb, Stra3, Tgfb4, lefty, lefty-1}, Gapdh (glyceraldehyde-3-phosphate dehydrogenase) [NCBI Gene 14433] {aka Gapd}, Tfcp2l1 (transcription factor CP2-like 1) [NCBI Gene 81879] {aka 1810030F05Rik, 4932442M07Rik, Cp2l1, Crtr-1, D930018N21Rik, LBP-9}, Sox7 (SRY (sex determining region Y)-box 7) [NCBI Gene 20680], LOC131389158 (STARR-seq mESC enhancer starr_41922) [NCBI Gene 131389158], LOC131378000 (STARR-seq mESC enhancer starr_28537) [NCBI Gene 131378000], LOC131391421 (STARR-seq mESC enhancer starr_46548) [NCBI Gene 131391421], LOC131392003 (STARR-seq mESC enhancer starr_47325) [NCBI Gene 131392003], LOC131339480 (STARR-seq mESC enhancer starr_09942) [NCBI Gene 131339480], LOC131371995 (STARR-seq mESC enhancer starr_16241) [NCBI Gene 131371995], LOC131379224 (STARR-seq mESC enhancer starr_30394) [NCBI Gene 131379224], LOC131372161 (STARR-seq mESC enhancer starr_16614) [NCBI Gene 131372161], LOC131373522 (STARR-seq mESC enhancer starr_19481) [NCBI Gene 131373522], LOC131295521 (STARR-seq mESC enhancer starr_00830) [NCBI Gene 131295521], LOC131372160 (STARR-seq mESC enhancer starr_16610) [NCBI Gene 131372160], LOC131373946 (STARR-seq mESC enhancer starr_20345) [NCBI Gene 131373946]
- **Diseases:** SL (MESH:C564794), PD (MESH:D010300), ERVs (MESH:D003866)
- **Chemicals:** glycine (MESH:D005998), oil (MESH:D009821), MtH (MESH:D008926), agarose (MESH:D012685), deoxycholate (MESH:D003840), polyA (MESH:D011061), HCl (MESH:D006851), salt (MESH:D012492), Nocodazole (MESH:D015739), CHIR99021 (MESH:C473711), PD0325901 (MESH:C506614), puromycin (MESH:D011691), EDTA (MESH:D004492), SDS (MESH:D012967), NP-40 (MESH:C010615), 2iL (-), IP (MESH:C041508), formaldehyde (MESH:D005557), nitrogen (MESH:D009584), LiCl (MESH:D018021), LIF (MESH:C027651), NaCl (MESH:D012965), PBS (MESH:D007854)
- **Species:** Mus musculus (house mouse, species) [taxon 10090], Drosophila melanogaster (fruit fly, species) [taxon 7227], Erysiphe sp. RV (species) [taxon 662690], Homo sapiens (human, species) [taxon 9606]
- **Cell lines:** S2C-D — Mus musculus (Mouse), Hybridoma (CVCL_C5DS), 2iL — Homo sapiens (Human), Melanoma, Cancer cell line (CVCL_B6KD), S2H — Homo sapiens (Human), Soft tissue sarcoma, Cancer cell line (CVCL_JB75), mESC — Mus musculus (Mouse), Embryonic stem cell (CVCL_4378), HeLa-S3 — Homo sapiens (Human), Human papillomavirus-related endocervical adenocarcinoma, Cancer cell line (CVCL_0058), SL — Homo sapiens (Human), Lung small cell carcinoma, Cancer cell line (CVCL_7010), S2 — Drosophila melanogaster (Fruit fly), Spontaneously immortalized cell line (CVCL_Z232), E14 — Mus musculus (Mouse), Embryonic stem cell (CVCL_9108), MEF — Mus musculus (Mouse), Finite cell line (CVCL_9115)

## Full text

_Full body text omitted from this summary view._ Fetch the complete paper as Markdown: https://tomesphere.com/paper/PMC7488044/full.md

## Figures

5 figures with captions in the complete paper: https://tomesphere.com/paper/PMC7488044/full.md

## References

99 references — full list in the complete paper: https://tomesphere.com/paper/PMC7488044/full.md

---
Source: https://tomesphere.com/paper/PMC7488044