Neighborhood Self-Selection: The Role of Pre-Move Health Factors on the Built and Socioeconomic Environment

TL;DR

This study examines how health factors before moving influence neighborhood choices, finding that higher BMI is linked to moving to less dense and lower-income areas.

Contribution

The study quantifies the impact of pre-move health factors on neighborhood selection, revealing potential biases in health-environment research.

Findings

Higher pre-move BMI is associated with moving to less dense counties with lower socioeconomic status.

Pre-move BMI is linked to moving to neighborhoods with higher poverty levels and lower income and home values.

Healthy pre-move behaviors are associated with moves to worse socioeconomic environments, potentially biasing health studies.

Abstract

Residential self-selection bias is a concern in studies of neighborhoods and health. This bias results from health behaviors predicting neighborhood choice. To quantify this bias, we examined associations between pre-move health factors (body mass index, walking, and total physical activity) and post-move neighborhood factors (County Sprawl Index, Census tract socioeconomic status (SES)) in the Nurses’ Health Study (n = 14,159 moves from 1986–2008). Individuals in the highest quartile of pre-move BMI (BMI > 28.4) compared to the lowest quartile (BMI < 22.5) moved to counties that averaged 2.57 points lower on the sprawl index (95% confidence interval −3.55, −1.59) indicating that individuals moved to less dense counties; however, no associations were observed for pre-move walking nor total physical activity. Individuals with higher pre-move BMI tended to move to Census tracts with lower median income and home values and higher levels of poverty. Analyses examining the change in neighborhood environments after a move demonstrated that healthy pre-move behaviors were associated with moves to worse socioeconomic environments. This type of self-selection would bias results downward, underestimating the true relationship between SES and physical activity. Generally, the magnitudes of associations between pre-move health factors and neighborhood measures were small and indicated that residential self-selection was not a major source of bias in analyses in this population.