# A Deep Dive into the Globin Superfamily of Sharks, Skates, and Rays: Contrasting Patterns of Gene Loss and Retention Relative to Bony Vertebrates

## TL;DR

This study explores how the globin gene family evolved in cartilaginous fish like sharks and skates, revealing patterns of gene loss and retention compared to bony vertebrates.

## Contribution

The study provides new insights into globin gene evolution in cartilaginous fish using newly available genomic resources.

## Key findings

- Most globin genes in cartilaginous fish are present in single copies, with differential retention of globin-X paralogs between elasmobranchs and Holocephali.
- Neuroglobin was lost in the common ancestor of all cartilaginous fish, and α- and β-globin subfamilies expanded independently in different lineages.
- Hemoglobin paralogs show broader expression in embryonic tissues compared to later stages when multiple copies exist.

## Abstract

The globin gene superfamily encodes oxygen-binding proteins that are present in all domains of life. Hemoglobin and myoglobin of jawed vertebrates are among the most well-studied proteins in the context of structure–function relationships and evolution after gene duplication. However, these studies have primarily focused on bony vertebrates, and research on the evolution of the globin gene family in cartilaginous fish has been limited by a lack of genomic resources. In this study, we leverage newly available cartilaginous fish genomes to investigate globin gene family evolution across skates, rays, sharks, and sawfish. We found that, when present, most globin genes are in a single copy, with androglobin, globin-Y, and myoglobin present in all cartilaginous fish, whereas the two globin-X paralogs of gnathostomes have been differentially retained by elasmobranchs (sharks, skates, and rays), which retained paralog 1, and the Holocephali, which retained paralog 2. Neuroglobin appears to have been lost at the common ancestor of all cartilaginous fish. The α- and β-globin gene subfamilies underwent independent expansions in different lineages of cartilaginous fish. Most cartilaginous fish globins have conserved synteny with other jawed vertebrates except myoglobin. Additionally, Nprl3, which directly flanks the hemoglobin clusters of other jawed and jawless vertebrates and regulates hemoglobin gene expression, is on a separate chromosome from the hemoglobin clusters of cartilaginous fish. When we examined globin gene expression patterns across cartilaginous fish tissues and developmental stages, we found that most globins are expressed as expected compared to other jawed vertebrates. However, hemoglobin paralogs are more widely expressed in embryonic tissues compared to later-stage tissues in cases where many copies exist. Our results reveal similar and contrasting patterns of globin gene evolution between cartilaginous and bony vertebrates and shed light on the early stages of globin gene evolution in gnathostomes.