Grounding psychosis research: why observable signs should anchor biological investigations

TL;DR

The paper argues that focusing on observable signs, rather than abstract symptoms, can improve biological research into psychosis.

Contribution

The novel proposal is the use of a Minimal Grounding Set (MGS) to anchor biological investigations in observable signs of psychosis.

Findings

Biological correlates will be more replicable when using the Minimal Grounding Set (MGS).

MGS can serve as modular anchors in symptom networks for psychosis research.

Precision medicine in psychiatry depends on distinguishing MGS from ungrounded symptoms.

Abstract

Biological psychiatry faces a significant epistemic challenge in identifying valid objects for mechanistic research. Both diagnostic constructs and individual symptoms are abstract symbols defined circularly within a closed hermeneutic system, creating a symbol grounding problem that hinders the discovery of biophysical substrates (biomarkers). I argue that progress requires an epistemological separation between the ungrounded symptoms such as delusions and hallucinations, which are co-constructed through personal and clinical interpretation from grounded signs that are directly observable features anchored in shared sensorimotor reality. I propose that a Minimal Grounding Set (MGS) can be recovered from the commonly used criteria for psychosis. This MGS, exemplified by disorganization and impoverishment, offers a privileged pathway for the neuroscientific inquiry of psychosis. In this case, (1) biological correlates will be most replicable for MGS than other symptoms; (2) MGS will serve as modular anchors in symptom networks; and (3) progress in precision medicine programs like Computational Psychiatry and quantitative psychopathology frameworks such as hierarchical taxonomy (HiTOP) will depend on explicitly separating MGS from ungrounded symptoms. This approach of sign-first psychiatry will provide a non-circular foundation to tether abstract constructs affiliated with psychosis to biological realities that have eluded us for long.

Figures