# Population structure and phylogenetic analysis of Vibrio cholerae non-O1/O139 by whole genome sequencing

**Authors:** Taylor Wells, Elizabeth González-Durán, Anthony M. Smith, Swapan K. Banerjee, Sandeep Tamber, Natalie Knox, Celine Nadon, Rahul Mandal, Rahul Mandal, Rahul Mandal, Rahul Mandal

PMC · DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0343306 · 2026-03-05

## TL;DR

This study uses whole genome sequencing to analyze the genetic relationships and population structure of non-O1/O139 Vibrio cholerae isolates in Canada, identifying new lineages and their potential to cause disease.

## Contribution

The study identifies eight new NOVC lineages in Canada and reveals their genetic diversity and potential pathogenicity.

## Key findings

- Eight new NOVC lineages (CAD1–8) were identified from Canadian isolates.
- Some NOVC lineages spanned multiple years and regions, including one linked to a 2018 outbreak.
- Virulence genes varied between clinical and environmental isolates, indicating differing pathogenic potential.

## Abstract

Toxigenic Vibrio cholerae serogroups O1 and O139 are well known for causing excessive diarrhea leading to devastating cholera epidemics and pandemics. Over 200 other serogroups, usually lacking the cholera toxin, are denoted non-O1/O139 V. cholerae (NOVC), and cause vibriosis leading to sporadic gastroenteritis and other extraintestinal infections. NOVC infections are not a notifiable disease in Canada and thus underreported. From 2010 to 2023, 160 cases and a small 2018 outbreak were reported in Canada caused by NOVC, provoking considerable public health concern. In this study, 242 Canadian V. cholerae isolates were sequenced, characterized and compared with over 1500 other V. cholerae isolates from around the world to determine their genetic relationships. All Canadian NOVC and two O139 isolates lacked the cholera toxin-producing genes typically harbored by pathogenic O1 and O139. All 14 Canadian O1 isolates were identified from travel-related cases as members of the toxigenic 7th pandemic lineage, whereas one O139 isolate was acquired domestically. Phylogenetic analysis based on core genome single nucleotide polymorphisms classified the Canadian isolates into five clades. Eight new lineages of NOVC, denoted CAD1–8, were identified from the Canadian isolates. A new lineage was defined as clusters formed by three or more isolates in the phylogeny. These lineages were comprised of isolates from clinical origin alone, environmental origin, or a mixture of both. Some lineages spanned multiple years and regions. CAD-2 was comprised of clinical and environmental isolates associated with the 2018 outbreak. Several virulence genes were detected among NOVC, including hemolysins, toxins and secretion system encoding genes. A proportion of virulence genes differed between isolation source (clinical or environmental) and clinical manifestations (gastrointestinal or extraintestinal). Our study identified environmental sources of NOVC with the potential to cause human infection. Tracking the emergence of NOVC with pathogenic potential is essential for understanding the risk to Canadians.

## Linked entities

- **Diseases:** cholera (MONDO:0015766), gastroenteritis (MONDO:0002269)
- **Species:** Vibrio cholerae (taxon 666)

## Full-text entities

- **Genes:** hapA (hemagglutinin/proteinase HapA) [NCBI Gene 69721545] {aka F0316_15570}, NEU1 (neuraminidase 1) [NCBI Gene 4758] {aka NANH, NEU, SIAL1}, sul2 [NCBI Gene 18156529]
- **Diseases:** diarrhea (MESH:D003967), CAD-2 (MESH:D020803), AMR (MESH:C565965), NOVC (MESH:D002771), nausea (MESH:D009325), Enteric (MESH:D004751), bacterial infections (MESH:D001424), septicemia (MESH:D018805), colon carcinoma (MESH:D003110), vomiting (MESH:D014839), Infectious Disease (MESH:D003141), watery diarrhea (MESH:D003969), Fever (MESH:D005334), foodborne disease (MESH:D005517), CAD-1 (MESH:C538557), cardiotoxicity (MESH:D066126), abdominal cramps (MESH:D003085), Gastroenteritis (MESH:D005759), keratitis (MESH:D007634), deaths (MESH:D003643), necrotizing fasciitis (MESH:D019115), inflammation of (MESH:D007249), Vibrio infections (MESH:D014735), meningitis (MESH:D008580), endophthalmitis (MESH:D009877), wound infection (MESH:D014946), cytotoxicity (MESH:D064420), eye and urinary tract infections (MESH:D014552), gastrointestinal (n (MESH:D005767), bacteremia (MESH:D016470), fatalities (MESH:C565541), extraintestinal infections (MESH:D007239)
- **Chemicals:** sulfisoxazole (MESH:D013444), trimethoprim-sulfamethoxazole (MESH:D015662), meropenem (MESH:D000077731), cefepime (MESH:D000077723), tetracyclines (MESH:D013754), sialic acids (MESH:D012794), CAZ (MESH:D002442), carbapenems (MESH:D015780), lipopolysaccharide (MESH:D008070), nalidixic acid (MESH:D009268), AMP (MESH:D000249), nitrofurans (MESH:D009581), ampicillin (MESH:D000667), water (MESH:D014867), chloramphenicol (MESH:D002701), beta-lactam (MESH:D047090), tetracycline (MESH:D013752), O-antigen (MESH:D019081), nitrofurantoin (MESH:D009582), FEP (MESH:D011138), azithromycin (MESH:D017963), sulfamethoxazole (MESH:D013420), CEF (-), streptomycin (MESH:D013307), furazolidone (MESH:D005664), RIF (MESH:D012293), SMZ (MESH:D013418), TMP (MESH:D013938), quinolones (MESH:D015363), agar (MESH:D000362), ciprofloxacin (MESH:D002939), ceftriaxone (MESH:D002443), sulfonamides (MESH:D013449), trimethoprim (MESH:D014295), cephalosporins (MESH:D002511)
- **Species:** Vibrio vulnificus (species) [taxon 672], Vibrio parahaemolyticus (species) [taxon 670], Shigella (genus) [taxon 620], Vibrio cholerae O139 (serogroup) [taxon 45888], Vibrio alginolyticus (species) [taxon 663], Chiltoniidae sp. AD1 (species) [taxon 1745265], Ochrobactrum sp. 13.9 (species) [taxon 1772266], Ophiostoma sp. 1 (species) [taxon 2268574], Bacteriophage sp. (species) [taxon 38018], Vibrio cholerae O1 (serogroup) [taxon 127906], Danio rerio (leopard danio, species) [taxon 7955], Tilapia (genus) [taxon 8126], Escherichia coli (E. coli, species) [taxon 562], Vibrio (genus) [taxon 662], Salmonella (genus) [taxon 590], Listeria monocytogenes (species) [taxon 1639], Vibrio mimicus (species) [taxon 674], Vibrio sp. sp1 (species) [taxon 2766781], Vibrio diabolicus (species) [taxon 50719], Homo sapiens (human, species) [taxon 9606], Canis lupus familiaris (dog, subspecies) [taxon 9615], Mus musculus (house mouse, species) [taxon 10090], Vibrio cholerae (species) [taxon 666]
- **Mutations:** S85L, S83I, C to -15

## Figures

7 figures with captions in the complete paper: https://tomesphere.com/paper/PMC12962490/full.md

---
Source: https://tomesphere.com/paper/PMC12962490