# A New Spin on Journal Club: Using Evidence-Based Arguments to Debate Research News

**Authors:** Karie Turley, Terence R. Mitchell, Bonnie Brenseke

PMC · DOI: 10.1007/s40670-025-02531-4 · 2025-11-08

## TL;DR

Students in a biomedical master's program debate health-related news findings using scientific evidence in a journal club format.

## Contribution

Introduces a debate-style journal club to enhance critical thinking and evidence-based argumentation in biomedical education.

## Key findings

- The debate-style journal club effectively engages students in evaluating health-related news findings.
- Students positively received the approach as it mirrors real-life scientific evaluation scenarios.

## Abstract

Biomedical master’s students participate in a debate-style journal club that challenges them to evaluate a health-related finding reported in the news. Assigned opposing views, students must defend their position using evidence from the scientific literature. This approach to journal club mirrors real-life situations and has been positively received by students.

## Full-text entities

- **Diseases:** respiratory disease (MESH:D012140)
- **Chemicals:** alcohol (MESH:D000438)
- **Species:** Homo sapiens (human, species) [taxon 9606]

---
Source: https://tomesphere.com/paper/PMC12960975