# Narrow Versus Broad Phenotype Definitions Affect Genetic Analysis of Language More than Other Broad Autism Phenotype Traits

**Authors:** Mudassir K. Lodi, Judy F. Flax, Christine Gwin, Sherri Wilson, Amber Robinson, Steven Buyske, Linda M. Brzustowicz, Jinchuan Xing, Christopher W. Bartlett

PMC · DOI: 10.3390/genes17020125 · Genes · 2026-01-25

## TL;DR

This study explores how different definitions of autism and language traits affect genetic analysis, identifying new candidate genes linked to language and reading impairments.

## Contribution

The study expands the genetic analysis of autism and language traits by using broader phenotypic definitions and identifying novel candidate genes.

## Key findings

- Previous findings on 15q and 16q are only relevant to narrow ASD and language impairment phenotypes.
- Ten and six top candidate risk genes were identified for language impairment and reading impairment, respectively.
- Some genes are newly implicated in neurodevelopmental disorders despite prior evidence of involvement.

## Abstract

Background/Objectives: Autism spectrum disorder (ASD) is a heritable neurodevelopmental condition that displays heterogeneity in both presentation and etiology, and often presents with concomitant communication difficulties. The hypothesis behind the New Jersey Language and Autism Genetic Study is that genetic heterogeneity for component phenotypes of ASD may be reduced relative to the disorder as a whole. We previously published an initial phase of this study with family recruitment that used very restricted inclusion/exclusion criteria for both autism and language deficits. Here, we present an expanded sample that includes a wider range of phenotypic presentations in the autism and language domains. Methods: Bioinformatics tools focusing on variant prioritization were used to identify candidate risk genes. Results: Our previous findings on 15q and 16q, connecting ASD and oral/written communication, are only relevant to the narrow ASD and language impairment phenotypes, though addition of families did reduce both critical regions. After variant and gene prioritization, we determined a set of ten and six top candidate risk genes with a strong association with language impairment and reading impairment, respectively. The top candidate genes include both genes previously implicated in neurodevelopmental disorders (e.g., ZNF774 and DNAH3) and genes not previously reported but with strong evidence of being involved in neurodevelopmental phenotypes. Conclusions: Our analysis elucidates the genetic architecture and interaction of ASD and language-related phenotypes. In addition, we reported a number of high-confidence candidate genes within the top linkage regions. These genes will provide insights into the genetic etiology of neurodevelopmental disorders.

## Linked entities

- **Genes:** ZNF774 (zinc finger protein 774) [NCBI Gene 342132], DNAH3 (dynein axonemal heavy chain 3) [NCBI Gene 55567]
- **Diseases:** autism spectrum disorder (MONDO:0005258)

## Full-text entities

- **Genes:** WASF1 (WASP family member 1) [NCBI Gene 8936] {aka NEDALVS, SCAR1, WAVE, WAVE-1, WAVE1}, DNAH3 (dynein axonemal heavy chain 3) [NCBI Gene 55567] {aka DNAHC3-B, DNAHC3B, HDHC8, HEL-36, HSADHC3}, ZNF774 (zinc finger protein 774) [NCBI Gene 342132], SCAPER (S-phase cyclin A associated protein in the ER) [NCBI Gene 49855] {aka IDDRP, MSTP063, ZNF291, Zfp291}, CTSH (cathepsin H) [NCBI Gene 1512] {aka ACC-4, ACC-5, ACC4, ACC5, CPSB}, ACAN (aggrecan) [NCBI Gene 176] {aka AGC1, AGCAN, CSPG1, CSPGCP, MSK16, SEDK}, CPEB1 (cytoplasmic polyadenylation element binding protein 1) [NCBI Gene 64506] {aka CPE-BP1, CPEB, CPEB-1, h-CPEB, hCPEB-1}, XYLT1 (xylosyltransferase 1) [NCBI Gene 64131] {aka DBQD2, PXYLT1, XT-I, XT1, XTI, XYLTI}, DNAJA4 (DnaJ heat shock protein family (Hsp40) member A4) [NCBI Gene 55466] {aka MST104, MSTP104, PRO1472}, EREG (epiregulin) [NCBI Gene 2069] {aka EPR, ER, Ep}, ADAMTSL3 (ADAMTS like 3) [NCBI Gene 57188] {aka ADAMTSL-3}, WASF2 (WASP family member 2) [NCBI Gene 10163] {aka IMD2, SCAR2, WASF4, WAVE2, dJ393P12.2}, SMG1 (SMG1 nonsense mediated mRNA decay associated PI3K related kinase) [NCBI Gene 23049] {aka 61E3.4, ATX, LIP}, SRS [NCBI Gene 140821], FOXM1 (forkhead box M1) [NCBI Gene 2305] {aka FKHL16, FOXM1A, FOXM1B, FOXM1C, HFH-11, HFH11}
- **Diseases:** IV (MESH:D006011), OCD (MESH:D009771), intellectual developmental disorder (MESH:C567016), social (OMIM:300082), speech disorder (MESH:D013064), dysfunction (MESH:D006331), BSS (MESH:C535943), DSM (MESH:D001714), RIRB (MESH:D002313), rigidity (MESH:D009127), NDD (MESH:D002658), related (MESH:D019973), motor impairments (MESH:D000068079), cognitive deficits (MESH:D003072), communication impairments (MESH:D003147), brain injury (MESH:D001930), intellectual disability (MESH:D008607), Tourette Syndrome (MESH:D005879), neurodevelopmental delay (MESH:D006968), Developmental Language Disorder (MESH:D007805), LI (MESH:D007806), PPL (MESH:C536741), DLD (MESH:D000080888), neurological disorders (MESH:D009461), -related phenotypes (MESH:D000077733), neurodegenerative diseases (MESH:D019636), injury to (MESH:D014947), neurodevelopmental condition (MESH:D020763), RI (MESH:D004410), inflammatory (MESH:D007249), Parkinson's disease (MESH:D010300), ASD (MESH:D000067877), Impairment in the amygdala (MESH:D060825), Alzheimer's disease (MESH:D000544), Mental Disorders (MESH:D001523), AD (MESH:D001321)
- **Chemicals:** lipids (MESH:D008055), TPM (-), heparan sulfate (MESH:D006497), GAG (MESH:D006025), carbohydrate (MESH:D002241), chondroitin sulfate (MESH:D002809), polysaccharides (MESH:D011134)
- **Species:** Homo sapiens (human, species) [taxon 9606], Mus musculus (house mouse, species) [taxon 10090]
- **Mutations:** 21031053-C-T, 24800831-A-G, 17232234-A-G, 17353170-C-G, 86198852-C-T, 75982312-C-T, 89401362-G-T, 83296111-G-T, 18907410-A-G, 24950880-C-T, 89389050-C-T, 21008629-C-T, 18908268-C-T, 75975211-C-T, 84651321-C-T, 89401134-C-T, 20994160-A-G, 84506964-A-G, 24828224-A-G, 79750056-C-T, 75980780-A-G, 17211545-C-T, 90904468-C-T, 83240107-G-T, 23160057-C-T, 23080170-A-G, 76726530-C-T, 83499472-C-T, 24950845-C-T, 89400204-C-T, 79750609-A-C, 83478990-C-T

## Full text

_Full body text omitted from this summary view._ Fetch the complete paper as Markdown: https://tomesphere.com/paper/PMC12940878/full.md

## Figures

6 figures with captions in the complete paper: https://tomesphere.com/paper/PMC12940878/full.md

## References

95 references — full list in the complete paper: https://tomesphere.com/paper/PMC12940878/full.md

---
Source: https://tomesphere.com/paper/PMC12940878