Comparative Evaluation of Commercial Bulk-Fill Resin-Based Composites: Flexural Properties, Roughness, Water Sorption and Solubility, and Color Stability

TL;DR

This study compares the performance of different commercial bulk-fill resin composites in terms of strength, water absorption, surface roughness, and color stability.

Contribution

The study provides a comprehensive evaluation of commercially available bulk-fill resin composites under standardized conditions.

Findings

3M Bulk and the control showed the highest flexural strength.

Shofu Bulk and Ivoclar Flow had the lowest water sorption and solubility.

Color changes were significant in Shofu Bulk after coffee immersion and FGM Bulk after Pepsi immersion.

Abstract

Background/Objectives: Bulk-fill (BF) resin-based composites (RBCs) have become increasingly popular due to their efficient placement. However, there is a lack of comprehensive performance comparisons among commercially available BF RBCs. In standardized curing conditions, this study aimed to compare the mechanical performance, water sorption and solubility, surface roughness, and color stability of commercially available BF RBCs with different consistencies (flowable and packable). Methods: Ten BF RBCs, along with a conventional RBC (control), were evaluated. Flexural strength and elastic modulus were measured using a three-point bending test. Water sorption and solubility were assessed after 28-day water storage. Color (ΔE00) and surface roughness (ΔRa) changes were measured after 28-day immersion in water, Pepsi, or coffee. One-way ANOVA and Tukey’s tests analyzed the data. Results: 3M Flow, Shofu Bulk, and Ivoclar Flow revealed lower strength (p < 0.001) compared to 3M Bulk (132.17 ± 12.54 MPa) and the control (124.56 ± 15.60 MPa). Shofu Bulk (24.68 ± 12.55 µg/mm3) and Ivoclar Flow (27.11 ± 6.27 µg/mm3) were the least affected by water sorption. While Shofu Bulk (13.98 ± 11.39 µg/mm3), Ivoclar Flow (20.28 ± 6.64 µg/mm3), and SDR (20.84 ± 9.74 µg/mm3) exhibited the lowest solubility (p < 0.01). After water and Pepsi immersion, FGM Bulk showed a significant color change compared to 3M Bulk and Ivoclar Bulk (p < 0.05). Following coffee immersion, Shofu Bulk (17.38 ± 1.82) revealed significant color changes (p < 0.001). Increased surface roughness was observed in 3M Bulk and Ivoclar Bulk after water immersion, Shofu Bulk after Pepsi immersion, and FGM Bulk after coffee immersion. Conclusions: BF RBCs exhibit notable variability in their intrinsic properties. 3M Bulk and Control showed the highest strength, while Shofu Bulk had significant color changes.

Figures