# Phylogeny of waterfowl (Anseriformes) constructed using genome sequences provides insights into topological incongruences

**Authors:** Gang Wang, Tao Zhu, Xinye Zhang, Xufang Ren, Anqi Chen, Zhonghua Ning, Marcel van Tuinen, Lujiang Qu

PMC · DOI: 10.1093/molbev/msag018 · 2026-01-21

## TL;DR

This study uses genome sequences to clarify the evolutionary relationships among waterfowl species and identifies sources of conflicting signals in their phylogeny.

## Contribution

The study provides a well-resolved phylogenetic backbone for waterfowl and identifies incomplete lineage sorting and gene introgression as causes of gene-tree discordance.

## Key findings

- Phylogenetic relationships among waterfowl species were highly resolved using genome data.
- Four instances of phylogenetic incongruence were identified across chromosomes.
- Incomplete lineage sorting and gene introgression were found to contribute to gene-tree discordance.

## Abstract

The evolutionary history of waterfowl (Anseriformes) has long been a focal point of avian research. However, previous phylogenetic investigations have focused primarily on morphology or mitochondrial DNA or have lacked sufficient taxon sampling. Accompanied by observed phylogenetic incongruence and incomplete resolution, waterfowl phylogenetic branching patterns remain uncertain at various taxonomic ranks. To further validate phylogenetic relationships among higher waterfowl taxa and assess presence of conflicting signal, we assembled and analyzed 24 waterfowl genomes representing all waterfowl families and several subfamilies. Utilizing both newly acquired and previously obtained genomes, we constructed and analyzed seven DNA data classes, which yielded highly resolved phylogenetic trees including a time-calibrated tree. Most of these trees consistently and completely resolved the phylogenetic relationships of the included waterfowl species. Despite these efforts, our analysis across chromosomes uncovered four instances of phylogenetic incongruous signal. After minimizing tree estimation error through focus on whole-genome alignment dataset and by sequence simulation, analyses revealed that incomplete lineage sorting and gene introgression essentially contributed to all gene-tree discordance. The variable impact of both factors across distinct waterfowl nodes reflects an underlying complexity that warrants further interpretation. This study not only presents a strongly-supported and well-resolved phylogenetic backbone for the major waterfowl lineages, but also provides foundational data for subsequent comparative genomics studies of a more expanded set of waterfowl taxa.

## Linked entities

- **Species:** Anseriformes (taxon 8826)

## Full-text entities

- **Genes:** GCH1 [NCBI Gene 101789988], TST [NCBI Gene 101799781], PGD [NCBI Gene 101801278], CCL20 [NCBI Gene 101803013]
- **Diseases:** burn (MESH:D002056), IH (MESH:C565524), ILS (MESH:D015456), CDS (MESH:D010855)
- **Chemicals:** ethanol (MESH:D000431), AE (MESH:C538178), Buffer AL (-)
- **Species:** Spatula clypeata (Northern shoveler, species) [taxon 75838], Anatidae (waterfowl, family) [taxon 8830], Cairina moschata (muscovy, species) [taxon 8855], Spatula rhynchotis (Australasian shoveler, species) [taxon 45633], Tachyeres pteneres (species) [taxon 75881], Anas (ducks, genus) [taxon 8835], Bucephala (genus) [taxon 40832], Heteronetta atricapilla (species) [taxon 555264], Saccharomyces cerevisiae (baker's yeast, species) [taxon 4932], Anser (geese, genus) [taxon 8842], Aythya fuligula (tufted duck, species) [taxon 219594], Galloanserae (ducks, geese, chickens, fowl, quail, currasows and allies, superorder) [taxon 1549675], Anas superciliosa (Pacific black duck, species) [taxon 45632], Tadorna radjah [taxon 8889], Anser sp. (goose, species) [taxon 8847], Anas puna [taxon 75855], Anas platyrhynchos (duck, species) [taxon 8839], Cygnus atratus (black swan, species) [taxon 8868], Nettapus auritus (species) [taxon 658922], Cairina sp. (species) [taxon 8856], Pan troglodytes (chimpanzee, species) [taxon 9598], Chauna torquata (southern screamer, species) [taxon 30388], Melanitta nigra (common scoter, species) [taxon 198027], Asarcornis scutulata (species) [taxon 75869], Gorilla (genus) [taxon 9592], Anas diazi (Mexican duck, species) [taxon 75841], Dendrocygna arborea (black-billed whistling-duck, species) [taxon 8871], Stictonetta naevosa (freckled duck, species) [taxon 45637], Hymenolaimus (genus) [taxon 337035], Tadorna tadorna (common shelduck, species) [taxon 75865], Anseranas semipalmata (magpie goose, species) [taxon 8851], Homo sapiens (human, species) [taxon 9606], Anas zonorhyncha (Chinese spot-billed duck, species) [taxon 75864], Galliformes (landfowls, order) [taxon 8976], Pica pica (Common magpie, species) [taxon 34924], Bucephala clangula (common goldeneye, species) [taxon 107022], Anas fulvigula (mottled duck, species) [taxon 75846], Anas rubripes (American black duck, species) [taxon 75857], Drosophila melanogaster (fruit fly, species) [taxon 7227], Somateria mollissima (common eider, species) [taxon 76058], Coscoroba coscoroba (Coscoroba swan, species) [taxon 8863], Gallus gallus (bantam, species) [taxon 9031]

## Figures

3 figures with captions in the complete paper: https://tomesphere.com/paper/PMC12902361/full.md

---
Source: https://tomesphere.com/paper/PMC12902361