Estimating the Reduction in Genetic Diversity from Background Selection under Non-equilibrium Demography and Partial Selfing

TL;DR

This study examines how background selection affects genetic diversity in species with different mating systems and population histories.

Contribution

The paper introduces a new method to jointly estimate background selection, demography, and selfing rates from genomic data.

Findings

The classic-BGS model is robust to demographic non-equilibrium and low selfing rates but leads to biased DFE estimates.

High selfing rates cause poor estimation of both B¯ and DFE parameters.

The new method reduces bias and explains genetic diversity differences in Capsella species.

Abstract

The effect of natural selection on linked sites has been suggested to be a major determinant of genetic diversity. While it is in principle possible to estimate this effect from genome sequence data, interactions between selection, demography and inbreeding are expected to make inference less reliable. Here, we investigate whether the genome-wide reduction in diversity due to background selection (B¯) can be accurately estimated when populations are at demographic non-equilibrium and/or reproduce by partial self-fertilization. We show that the classic-BGS model is surprisingly robust to both demographic non-equilibrium and low rates of selfing, although both processes do lead to biased estimation of the distribution of fitness effects (DFE) of deleterious mutations. A high rate of selfing leads to poor estimation of both B¯ and DFE parameters. We propose an alternative approach where background selection, demography and partial selfing are jointly estimated from windowed site frequency spectra. This approach resolves most of the bias observed under the classic-BGS model and can also generate estimates of past demography that account for the effect of background selection and partial selfing. We apply the approach to genome sequence data from Capsella grandiflora and Capsella orientalis, which have contrasting mating systems and display a forty-fold difference in nucleotide diversity. Our results suggest that background selection has a weak effect on levels of genetic diversity in the outcrosser C. grandiflora (B¯=0.89) and a more substantial effect in the predominantly selfing species C. orientalis (B¯=0.44), but that background selection alone cannot explain their disparity in genetic diversity.

Figures