# Cognitive gene enhancements and the capitalist meritocracy

## TL;DR

The paper argues that cognitive gene enhancements may be driven by oppressive norms of the capitalist meritocracy, undermining their authenticity and moral permissibility.

## Contribution

The novel argument is that the value of cognitive enhancements is shaped by oppressive capitalist norms, not just their impact on autonomy.

## Key findings

- Cognitive enhancements may reflect oppressive norms of superintelligence and productivity.
- The capitalist meritocracy influences the perceived legitimacy of genetic modifications.
- The autonomy of using cognitive gene enhancements is questionable within oppressive systems.

## Abstract

The relationship between cognitive enhancements (CE) and human autonomy or authenticity is generally positioned as how CE impact human autonomy or authenticity. But rarely, if ever, do we consider whether the value and pursuit of CE is an authentic one. In this paper, I will argue that the moral permissibility of cognitive gene enhancements is undone by the legitimate concern that the near universal value for such modifications is likely driven by oppressive norms for superintelligence and productivity. I argue that these norms derive from the capitalist meritocracy: an economic system that structures inclusion and success based on patriarchal and racist norms of intelligence and productivity. The claim that the use of such enhancements fits within the autonomous scope of individual power is thus far weaker than it claims to be, particularly within the context of genetic modification.