Enhancing Molecular Diagnostic Accuracy in Genetic Eye Disorders Through a Personalized Re-Evaluation Strategy

TL;DR

A personalized re-evaluation strategy improves genetic diagnosis rates in eye disorders by combining updated testing and expert review.

Contribution

A tailored re-evaluation approach increased diagnostic yield by over 10% in genetic eye disorders.

Findings

Initial testing diagnosed 59.4% of families, increasing to 70.1% after re-evaluation.

Personalized re-testing resolved 43 additional cases using updated panels and variant analysis.

Periodic re-evaluation and improved methodologies led to 86 additional definitive diagnoses.

Abstract

Although genetic testing is crucial to provide prognostic information in genetic eye disorders (GEDs), up to 35% of cases remain unsolved after testing. We aim to describe how a tailored re-evaluation strategy, using up-to-date molecular testing, case-by-case review, and integration of in silico tools may increase the diagnostic yield.

A total of 988 individuals from 800 families evaluated at the largest Portuguese GED referral center (Hospitais da Universidade de Coimbra) were included. All had a clinical diagnosis based on clinical findings and deep phenotyping and underwent genetic testing. Targeted re-evaluation included updated Next Generation Sequencing (NGS) panels, Exome Sequencing (ES) reanalysis, and assays for intronic variants, copy number variants, and ORF15-RPGR region. Variants of uncertain significance (VUS) were reassessed using segregation studies, literature/database review, and bioinformatic tools.

Initial testing yielded a molecular diagnosis in 475 families (59.4%). Variant reclassification enabled 39 additional diagnoses. A personalized re-testing strategy resolved 43 more, either through updated NGS panels (11), ES-reanalysis (14) and identification of deletions, GC-rich, and intronic variants (22). Overall, the solved rate increased from 59.4% to 70.1%. An additional 45 families (5.6%) carry phenotype-consistent VUS that could not be reclassified at the present date (partially-solved cases).

This personalized re-evaluation strategy, incorporating state-of-the-art genetic testing, evidence-based variant reclassification, and case review by a multidisciplinary team increased the solved rate by over 10%. Consequently, 86 additional families received a definitive diagnosis and accurate genetic counseling, underscoring the impact of periodic re-evaluation and continuous improvement in genetic testing methodologies.

Figures