# Hierarchical Mechanistic Modeling of Complex Toxicity Endpoints from Public Concentration–Response Data

**Authors:** Elena Chung, Daniel P. Russo, Lauren M. Aleksunes, Genoa R. Warner, Hao Zhu

PMC · DOI: 10.1021/acs.est.5c09326 · 2026-01-13

## TL;DR

This paper introduces a new framework that organizes and interprets high-throughput screening data to predict toxicity outcomes and understand biological pathways.

## Contribution

A hierarchical mechanistic modeling framework that integrates HTS data with biological pathways to predict toxicity and enhance interpretability.

## Key findings

- Integrated 455 PubChem assays with 216 protein targets and 103 biological pathways.
- Generated pathway-level toxicity scores for five in vivo toxicity endpoints.
- Linked chemical bioactivity to adverse outcomes for compound ranking and hazard prediction.

## Abstract

High-throughput screening (HTS) programs have generated
abundant
data on numerous chemicals, supporting the discovery of toxicity mechanisms
and advancing understanding of adverse outcome pathways (AOPs) in
chemical toxicity. However, organizing and interpreting these data
for predictive modeling remain challenging due to inconsistent repository
formats, varied program objectives, heterogeneous assay targets, and
differences in experimental protocols, including concentration ranges.
To address these limitations, we developed a hierarchical mechanistic
modeling framework that systematically structures and interprets concentration
response HTS data. The model integrated curated data sets by mapping
metadata from 455 PubChem assays to 216 protein targets and 103 biological
pathways in WikiPathways. Assay-level concentration–response
data were organized within a biologically layered hierarchy to construct
AOP-based models. The resulting models generated pathway-level toxicity
scores that quantified compound potency by integrating inferred protein
activity and downstream pathway perturbations. In total, 103 pathways
were statistically associated with five in vivo toxicity
endpoints: acute systemic, maternal, developmental, human hepatotoxicity,
and preclinical hepatotoxicity. This hierarchical framework leverages
HTS metadata to predict diverse in vivo toxicity
outcomes and enhance mechanistic interpretability of pathway-level
effects. It links chemical bioactivity to adverse outcomes, providing
a quantitative basis for compound ranking, potency assessment, and
hazard prediction. Overall, this framework offers a structured, scalable
method for integrating large bioactivity data sets into computational
toxicology, supporting chemical risk assessment and early-stage drug
discovery.

## Full-text entities

- **Genes:** CYP3A4 (cytochrome P450 family 3 subfamily A member 4) [NCBI Gene 1576] {aka CP33, CP34, CYP3A, CYP3A3, CYPIIIA3, CYPIIIA4}, AR (androgen receptor) [NCBI Gene 367] {aka AIS, AR8, DHTR, HPCX3, HUMARA, HYSP1}, TXK (TXK tyrosine kinase) [NCBI Gene 7294] {aka BTKL, PSCTK5, PTK4, RLK, TKL}, ACHE (acetylcholinesterase (Yt blood group)) [NCBI Gene 43] {aka ACEE, ARACHE, N-ACHE, YT}, KEAP1 (kelch like ECH associated protein 1) [NCBI Gene 9817] {aka INrf2, KLHL19}, TLR4 (toll like receptor 4) [NCBI Gene 7099] {aka ARMD10, CD284, TLR-4, TOLL}, AICDA (activation induced cytidine deaminase) [NCBI Gene 57379] {aka AID, ARP2, CDA2, HEL-S-284, HIGM2}, CTNNB1 (catenin beta 1) [NCBI Gene 1499] {aka CTNNB, EVR7, MRD19, NEDSDV, armadillo}, UNC5B (unc-5 netrin receptor B) [NCBI Gene 219699] {aka UNC5H2, p53RDL1}, NFE2L2 (NFE2 like bZIP transcription factor 2) [NCBI Gene 4780] {aka IMDDHH, NRF2, Nrf-2}, PPIG (peptidylprolyl isomerase G) [NCBI Gene 9360] {aka CARS-Cyp, CYP, SCAF10, SRCyp}, AHR (aryl hydrocarbon receptor) [NCBI Gene 196] {aka FVH3, RP85, bHLHe76}, GLI3 (GLI family zinc finger 3) [NCBI Gene 2737] {aka ACLS, GCPS, GLI3-190, GLI3FL, PAP-A, PAPA}, CYP2D6 (cytochrome P450 family 2 subfamily D member 6 (gene/pseudogene)) [NCBI Gene 1565] {aka CPD6, CYP2D, CYP2D7AP, CYP2D7BP, CYP2D7P2, CYP2D8P2}, CYP2C19 (cytochrome P450 family 2 subfamily C member 19) [NCBI Gene 1557] {aka CPCJ, CYP2C, CYPIIC17, CYPIIC19, P450C2C, P450IIC19}, CYP19A1 (cytochrome P450 family 19 subfamily A member 1) [NCBI Gene 1588] {aka ARO, ARO1, CPV1, CYAR, CYP19, CYPXIX}, ANGPTL8 (angiopoietin like 8) [NCBI Gene 55908] {aka C19orf80, PRO1185, PVPA599, RIFL, TD26}, SLC6A7 (solute carrier family 6 member 7) [NCBI Gene 6534] {aka PROT}, CYP1A2 (cytochrome P450 family 1 subfamily A member 2) [NCBI Gene 1544] {aka CP12, CYPIA2, P3-450, P450(PA)}, NFKB1 (nuclear factor kappa B subunit 1) [NCBI Gene 4790] {aka CVID12, EBP-1, KBF1, NF-kB, NF-kB1, NF-kappa-B1}, TP53 (tumor protein p53) [NCBI Gene 7157] {aka BCC7, BMFS5, LFS1, P53, TRP53}, CYP2C9 (cytochrome P450 family 2 subfamily C member 9) [NCBI Gene 1559] {aka CPC9, CYP2C, CYP2C10, CYPIIC9, P450-2C9, P450IIC9}, NR1I2 (nuclear receptor subfamily 1 group I member 2) [NCBI Gene 8856] {aka BXR, ONR1, PAR, PAR1, PAR2, PARq}, EPHB2 (EPH receptor B2) [NCBI Gene 2048] {aka BDPLT22, CAPB, DRT, EK5, EPHT3, ERK}, ESR1 (estrogen receptor 1) [NCBI Gene 2099] {aka ER, ESR, ESRA, ESTRR, Era, NR3A1}, COX2 (cytochrome c oxidase subunit II) [NCBI Gene 4513] {aka COII, MTCO2}
- **Diseases:** acute renal and hepatic toxicity (MESH:D058186), hepatotoxic compounds (MESH:D005597), Cornelia de Lange syndrome (MESH:D003635), Tox (MESH:D014012), cholinergic crisis (MESH:C535672), liver injury (MESH:D017093), reproductive, developmental, and metabolic disorders (MESH:D060737), ischemic stroke (MESH:D002544), porto-sinusoidal vascular disease (MESH:D000094724), growth retardation (MESH:D006130), respiratory failure (MESH:D012131), heartburn (MESH:D006356), cancers (MESH:D009369), malformations (MESH:C564254), liver tumors (MESH:D008113), Toxicity (MESH:D064420), liver fibrosis (MESH:D008103), maternal (MESH:D000079262), developmental disorders (MESH:D002658), embryonic lethality (MESH:D020964), tapeworm infections (MESH:D002590), steatotic liver disease (MESH:D008107), deaths (MESH:D003643), DILI (MESH:D056486), Alstrom syndrome (MESH:D056769), metabolic dysfunction (MESH:D008659), inflammatory (MESH:D007249)
- **Chemicals:** nimesulide (MESH:C012655), niclosamide (MESH:D009534), triazole (MESH:D014230), benzamide (MESH:C037689), sulfotep (MESH:C009359), kynurenine (MESH:D007737), UDP (MESH:D014530), labdane diterpene (MESH:D004224), Erlotinib (MESH:D000069347), Eliprodil (MESH:C058083), sugars (MESH:D000073893), pifexole (MESH:C003259), CAS 183321-74-6 (-), pecazine (MESH:C100190), penflutizide (MESH:C008781), Coumaphos (MESH:D003372), cisapride (MESH:D020117), phosphorus (MESH:D010758), ethion (MESH:C100038), Phenothiazines (MESH:D010640), Caffeine (MESH:D002110), Sulfonamide (MESH:D013449), aspirin (MESH:D001241), cyclothiazide (MESH:C004639), steroid (MESH:D013256), oxygen (MESH:D010100), althiazide (MESH:C006480), Colforsin (MESH:D005576), ethoprophos (MESH:C001182), organophosphate (MESH:D010755), NS-398 (MESH:C080955), Propiconazole (MESH:C045950)
- **Species:** Gallus gallus (bantam, species) [taxon 9031], Rattus norvegicus (brown rat, species) [taxon 10116], Severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 (no rank) [taxon 2697049], Mus musculus (house mouse, species) [taxon 10090], Homo sapiens (human, species) [taxon 9606]

## Figures

13 figures with captions in the complete paper: https://tomesphere.com/paper/PMC12854766/full.md

---
Source: https://tomesphere.com/paper/PMC12854766