Effect of Silicon on Early Root and Shoot Phenotypes of Rice in Hydroponic and Soil Systems

TL;DR

This study finds that silicon from zeolite improves rice root and shoot growth more in soil than in hydroponic systems.

Contribution

The study reveals that silicon source and growth medium significantly affect rice development, with zeolite being more effective in soil.

Findings

Zeolite-based silicon improved rice root traits more in soil than in hydroponics.

Silicon from zeolite increased photosynthetic efficiency and plant growth in soil conditions.

Soluble silicon sources are more effective in hydroponic systems compared to soil.

Abstract

Silicon (Si) application is recognized for its beneficial roles in crop growth. This study examines the effects of two forms: zeolite and sodium metasilicate (SMS), on rice under hydroponic (EP I) and soil (EP II) conditions. Four treatments were used at the early stage of rice: 4 ppm and 2 ppm of Si from zeolite, 4 ppm of Si from SMS, and a control. In EP I, only 4 ppm of SMS significantly improved root traits: total root length (36%), surface area (34%), root volume (23%), tips (46%), and forks (34%) by day seven compared to the control. Zeolite-based Si had minimal effects, except on the average diameter. However, in EP II, all Si forms enhanced root traits: total root length (50–73%), surface area (51–58%), average diameter (32–50%), root volume (54–72%), tips (29–68%) and increased shoot and root dry weights by 19–24% and 79–106%, respectively, compared to the control. In EP II, starting from the first and fifth day of treatment, the Si applied groups showed a significant increase in photosynthetic traits and vegetative indices, respectively. On the last day of treatment, particularly for 2 ppm of Si zeolite, the electron transport rate increased by 5 times, the apparent transpiration by 3 times, total conductance and stomatal conductance by around 50%, normalized difference vegetative index by 6–8%, and photochemical reflectance index by 14–33%. These results suggest that the effectiveness of Si is highly dependent on the growth medium and the type of Si, with soil enabling better Si availability, uptake, and physiological response compared to hydroponics. The superior performance of zeolite in EP II indicates its potential as a slow-release Si source that enhances root development and photosynthetic efficiency over time. Thus, it is concluded that zeolite has more potential in soil, and soluble silicon sources should be selected in hydroponics.

Figures