Ultrasound-Guided Nerve Blocks for Patients with Clavicle Fracture in the Emergency Department

TL;DR

Ultrasound-guided nerve blocks offer faster and better pain relief for clavicle fractures in the emergency department compared to standard care, without major side effects.

Contribution

This study demonstrates that ultrasound-guided nerve blocks are more effective for acute clavicle fracture pain than standard analgesic methods.

Findings

USNB provided significantly greater pain relief compared to standard care (p < 0.001).

USNB achieved meaningful pain relief 3.41 times faster than standard care (HR = 3.41; p = 0.004).

No USNB-related complications were observed in the study.

Abstract

Background: Opioids and nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs) for clavicle fracture pain management carry significant adverse effect and allergic reaction risks. This study assessed ultrasound-guided nerve block (USNB) efficacy for acute clavicle fracture pain in emergency department (ED) patients, providing an alternative to NSAIDs and opioids with fewer adverse effects. Methods: This retrospective, single-center observational study was conducted in accordance with Methods of Medical Record Review Studies in Emergency Medicine Research guidelines. Adult patients (≥20 years) who presented to the ED with traumatic clavicle fractures between 1 January 2015 and 30 November 2023 were included. Of the 343 eligible patients, 12 received ultrasound-guided nerve blocks (USNB) and 331 received standard care. To improve exchangeability, 1:10 matching with replacement was performed according to patients’ characteristics, such as age, sex, initial pain score, and comorbidities. The primary outcome was pain relief, assessed via the pain intensity difference (PID) on the Numerical Rating Scale within 360 min post-intervention. Meaningful pain relief was defined as a PID ≥ 4. Secondary outcomes included rescue opioid use, ED length of stay, hospital length of stay, and USNB-associated complications, such as vascular puncture, nerve injury, or local anesthetic systemic toxicity. Data were analyzed using time-course, time-to-event (time to meaningful pain relief), and linear regression analyses. Results: A total of 12 patients in the USNB group and 85 matched patients in the standard care group were analyzed after baseline characteristics matching with replacement. Compared to standard care, USNB was associated with significantly greater pain relief (p < 0.001). In the time-to-event analysis, USNB led to a 3.41-fold faster achievement of meaningful pain relief compared with that achieved with standard care (HR = 3.41; 95% CI, 1.47–7.90; p = 0.004). No significant differences were observed between groups in rescue opioid use, ED length of stay, or hospital length of stay. No USNB-associated complication developed in the USNB group. Conclusions: In patients with traumatic clavicle fractures, USNB provides more rapid and sustained pain relief than standard analgesic care in the ED, without increasing the ED length of stay. Large prospective studies are needed to confirm these findings.

Figures