# Explaining sex: contrast between social and sexual selection

**Authors:** Joan Roughgarden

PMC · DOI: 10.1186/s13293-025-00807-3 · Biology of Sex Differences · 2025-12-31

## TL;DR

The paper compares two theories explaining sexual reproduction: one based on competition and mating success, and another based on cooperation and offspring care.

## Contribution

The paper introduces an alternative framework called 'social selection' that contrasts with traditional sexual selection theory.

## Key findings

- Sexual selection theory relies on competition, conflict, and mating success.
- Social selection theory emphasizes negotiation, teamwork, and offspring delivery.
- The sexual selection system faces logical flaws and lacks factual support.

## Abstract

Darwin’s [The Descent of Man (2nd Edn.) (1871)] theory of sexual selection has been expanded into a system of interlocking hypotheses to explain many features of sexual reproduction. It focusses on mating success and relies on processes featuring bad genes, selfishness, competition, conflict, coercion, ownership and deceit. Logical flaws and an absence of factual support challenge the sexual-selection system. An alternative explanatory system, social selection, focusses on offspring delivery and relies on processes featuring negotiation, teamwork and division of labor. The sexual-selection system and the social-selection system differ in their world views of nature.

## Full-text entities

- **Diseases:** Hermaphroditism (MESH:D012734), aggressiveness (MESH:D010554), handicap (MESH:D009422), genetic defect (MESH:D030342), monomorphism (MESH:D000236), dystopia (MESH:D014849)
- **Species:** Thoracica (barnacles, infraclass) [taxon 6676], Labriformes (wrasses, order) [taxon 1489928], Serranidae (sea basses, family) [taxon 30871], Varanus komodoensis (Komodo dragon, species) [taxon 61221], Crocodylidae (crocodiles, family) [taxon 8493], Hexapoda (hexapods, subphylum) [taxon 6960], Actiniaria (actinians, order) [taxon 6103], Rhinobatos hynnicephalus (angel fish, species) [taxon 42863], Hydra (genus) [taxon 6083], Apis mellifera (bee, species) [taxon 7460], Chromis chromis (damselfish, species) [taxon 91607], Lepidosauria (lepidosaurs, class) [taxon 8504], Leptonotus elevatus (pipefish, species) [taxon 1095086], Gallus gallus (bantam, species) [taxon 9031], Kraemeriidae (sandfishes, family) [taxon 86202], Jacanidae (jacanas, family) [taxon 54504], Cyanistes caeruleus (Blaumeise, species) [taxon 156563], Cetacea (cetaceans, infraorder) [taxon 9721], Pan paniscus (bonobo, species) [taxon 9597], Ficedula albicollis (Collared flycatcher, species) [taxon 59894], PX clade (clade) [taxon 569578], Meleagris gallopavo (common turkey, species) [taxon 9103], Nymphalis io (European peacock, species) [taxon 171585], Ovis aries (domestic sheep, species) [taxon 9940], Lepomis macrochirus (bluegill, species) [taxon 13106], Drosophila melanogaster (fruit fly, species) [taxon 7227], Serpentes (snakes, infraorder) [taxon 8570], Hippocampinae (seahorses, subfamily) [taxon 129917], Rotifera (rotifers, phylum) [taxon 10190], Sus scrofa (pig, species) [taxon 9823], Aphidomorpha (aphids, infraorder) [taxon 33380], Hirundo rustica (Barn swallow, species) [taxon 43150], Gobiidae (burrowing gobies, family) [taxon 8220], Testudines (anapsid reptiles, order) [taxon 8459], Daphnia (common water fleas, genus) [taxon 6668], Homo sapiens (human, species) [taxon 9606], Sparidae (porgies, family) [taxon 8169], Labridae (parrotfishes, family) [taxon 8247], Diptera (flies, order) [taxon 7147], Selachii (sharks, infraclass) [taxon 119203], Jacana (genus) [taxon 54507]
- **Cell lines:** NESC2015 — Homo sapiens (Human), Transformed cell line (CVCL_K777), SK2021 — Homo sapiens (Human), Induced pluripotent stem cell (CVCL_C1S0)

## Full text

_Full body text omitted from this summary view._ Fetch the complete paper as Markdown: https://tomesphere.com/paper/PMC12837013/full.md

## References

2 references — full list in the complete paper: https://tomesphere.com/paper/PMC12837013/full.md

---
Source: https://tomesphere.com/paper/PMC12837013