Black People Living with Memory Challenges & Study Partners’ Preferred Activity Tracker Features

TL;DR

This study explores which activity tracker features Black people with memory challenges and their study partners prefer, to improve adherence in future research.

Contribution

The study identifies preferred activity tracker features among Black participants with memory challenges and their study partners.

Findings

PLMC preferred the Apple Watch SE for comfort and features like screen size and emergency button.

Study partners rated Fitbit Inspire 5 highest for comfort and Apple Watch SE for convenience and GPS.

Findings can guide future activity tracker selection for this population.

Abstract

Activity tracker preferences of Black people living with memory challenges (PLMC) or dementia and study partners are largely unknown, which can impact wear-time adherence. We sought to identify Black PLMC and study partners’ preferred activity tracker features. Participants (n = 10) were recruited from Eskenazi Health in Indianapolis, Indiana. Data were collected through two 90-minute focus groups with Black PLMC participants (n = 5) and Black study partners (n = 5), respectively, and a PLMC and study partner interview. The focus group was guided by a semi-structured questionnaire and involved interacting with an Apple Watch SE, Oura Ring Heritage, Fitbit Inspire 3, and Polar Watch Ignite. Participants ranked each device based on comfort (device size, weight, material), convenience (battery life, water resistance, style, emergency button), and features (e.g., activity, steps, time standing, calories, distance/GPS, heart rate, respiratory rate) from 1-5 using checklists and picture cards. Focus groups were audio recorded. Device rankings from each category (comfort, convenience, and features) were summarized with descriptive statistics. Audio recordings were analyzed using the Rapid Identification of Themes from Audio recordings method and transcribed. PLMC rated the Apple Watch SE with mean scores in comfort (4.00), convenience (3.33), and features (4.3),30) emphasizing screen size, viewing progress on the watch, and an emergency button. Study partners rated the Fitbit Inspire 5 most in comfort (5), while the Apple Watch SE had the most rankings for convenience (4.75) and features (5.00), highlighting the emergency button and GPS as key attributes. Findings can guide activity tracker selection in future studies with this population.