Effect of fascial closure using barbed sutures on incisional hernias in midline laparotomy for gynecological diseases: A multicenter randomized controlled trial (KGOG 4001)

TL;DR

This study compared barbed and non-barbed sutures for closing abdominal incisions in gynecological surgeries and found no significant difference in hernia rates.

Contribution

A multicenter trial evaluating barbed sutures for reducing incisional hernias in gynecological laparotomies.

Findings

No significant difference in 1-year hernia rates between barbed and non-barbed sutures.

No significant difference in 2-year hernia rates between the two suture types.

No significant differences in wound complications or postoperative pain between groups.

Abstract

To identify the effect of fascial closure using barbed sutures on the incidence of incisional hernia in patients undergoing elective midline laparotomy for gynecological diseases.

In this multicenter, non-blind randomized controlled trial conducted from February to December 2021, patients with a BMI < 35 kg/m2 and aged >18 years, scheduled for midline laparotomy, were randomly assigned to receive either barbed (experimental) or non-barbed sutures (control) for fascial closure. The primary outcome was the cumulative incidence rate of incisional hernia up to 1-year post-surgery. Secondary outcomes included incisional hernia up to 2-years post-surgery, wound complications, and postoperative pain assessed by Brief Pain Inventory-Korean scores, and Numeric Rating Scale.

Out of 174 patients (experimental, 86; control, 88), 36 were excluded due to dropout or loss to follow-up, leaving 138 patients (experimental, 67; control, 71) included in the analysis. The groups were balanced in terms of cancer surgeries, mean wound length, and mean surgery time. The cumulative incidence rates of incisional hernia up to 1-year (0.0% vs. 1.4%; p > 0.999) and 2-years (0.0% vs. 3.4%, p = 0.496) post-surgery did not differ significantly between the experimental and control groups. Additionally, no significant differences were observed in the incidence of wound dehiscence 4 weeks post-surgery, cumulative incidences of wound dehiscence and wound infection up to 4 weeks post-surgery, or postoperative pain scores between the groups.

Fascial closure using barbed sutures resulted in no cases of incisional hernia up to 2-years post-surgery, but did not demonstrate a significant reduction in incisional hernia rates compared with the non-barbed suture.

ClinicalTrials.gov NCT04643197

Figures