# EF1α and αTUB Are Stable Reference Gene Pairs for RT-qPCR-Based Gene Expression Studies in Salix suchowensis Under Nitrogen Treatment Conditions

## TL;DR

This study identifies EF1α and αTUB as reliable reference genes for gene expression analysis in Salix suchowensis under different nitrogen conditions.

## Contribution

The study provides the first validated reference gene pairs for RT-qPCR normalization in Salix species under varying nitrogen treatments.

## Key findings

- EF1α and αTUB showed the highest expression stability across tissues and nitrogen treatments.
- Five genes were excluded due to poor amplification or irregular melting curves.
- EF1α + αTUB is recommended as the optimal reference gene pair for RT-qPCR normalization in Salix under nitrogen stress.

## Abstract

Salix suchowensis is an ideal model organism for investigating nitrogen (N) transport mechanisms due to its low N-input requirements. Accurate quantification of gene expression is essential for elucidating these processes, with quantitative real-time PCR (RT-qPCR) being the preferred method. However, the identification of stable reference genes for normalization in Salix suchowensis under varying N conditions remains unresolved. In this study, thirteen commonly employed candidate reference genes were evaluated across root, stem, and leaf tissues, under four N treatments (NH4NO3, NH4+, NO3−, and N deficiency). Five genes (UBQ1, UBQ3, 18S, H2A2, and H2B2) were excluded due to poor amplification efficiency or irregular melting curves. The remaining eight genes were further assessed for expression stability using the geNorm, NormFinder, and BestKeeper algorithms. Integrated ranking via RefFinder identified EF1α, EFβ, and αTUB as the most stable reference genes. GeNorm analysis suggested that two reference genes were sufficient for reliable normalization. Validation using the N-responsive gene SsAMT1 and SsNRT2 confirmed the stability of EF1α, EFβ, and αTUB as suitable reference genes. Based on comprehensive stability assessments and experimental validation, we recommended EF1α + αTUB as optimal reference gene pairs for RT-qPCR normalization under varying N conditions. Furthermore, the consistent expression of EF1α and αTUB across nine willow genotypes highlighted their broader applicability within Salix species. This study provides valuable methodological guidance for advancing molecular research on N transport in woody perennial plants.