Isolated Polyethylene Exchange in Revision Total Knee Arthroplasty: A Review of Indications and Outcomes

TL;DR

This paper reviews the effectiveness of replacing only the polyethylene part in knee revision surgeries for issues like stiffness and infection.

Contribution

The paper provides a comprehensive review of indications and outcomes for isolated polyethylene exchange in revision TKA.

Findings

IPE may improve mild stiffness if implants are stable and well-positioned.

IDPE is effective for acute PJI if performed within two weeks of symptom onset.

Outcomes for IPE in instability remain inconsistent across studies.

Abstract

Introduction: The use of modular components provides several advantages in total knee arthroplasty (TKA), including exchange of the polyethylene insert while retaining the stable components in the revision TKA. Compared to full, non-modular component revision TKA, isolated polyethylene exchange (IPE) has the advantage of decreased morbidity, faster rehabilitation, and acceptable outcomes. Methods: A review of published literature on revision TKA was conducted, with a specific focus on studies evaluating the use of IPE for managing complications such as stiffness, instability, and periprosthetic joint infection (PJI). Results: IPE with downsizing may be considered for patients with mild stiffness and stable, well-positioned implants that have increased polyethylene thickness, though expectations for motion gain should be cautious. There is no clear consensus on IPE for instability. Some studies report high re-revision rates, while others show clinical and functional improvement when the TKA is well-aligned, well-fixed, and intraoperative gap balance is achieved. Additionally, irrigation and debridement with polyethylene exchange (IDPE) may be effective for acute TKA PJI management, particularly within the first two weeks of symptom onset. Conclusions: Based on current literature, IPE in aseptic TKA revisions may be effective for stiffness or instability when implants are well-fixed and well-aligned—particularly if polyethylene constraint can be adjusted for instability or downsized for stiffness. The role of IDPE in acute TKA PJI is better defined in the literature, with strong emphasis on its time-sensitive effectiveness—most notably within the first two weeks of symptom onset.