# Voluntary Additional Welfare Monitoring of Farm Animals Used in Research: Maximising Benefits Requires Sustained Support

## TL;DR

Researchers worked with staff to create voluntary animal welfare monitoring systems for farm animals in research, finding that sustained support is needed to maximize benefits.

## Contribution

A novel approach to co-creating voluntary animal welfare monitoring protocols with staff input in real research settings.

## Key findings

- Staff could design protocols to evaluate and promote positive animal emotions with facilitation.
- Data collection was inconsistent due to time constraints despite high staff valuation of the process.
- Sustained support is likely necessary to maximize benefits of voluntary welfare monitoring.

## Abstract

Monitoring animal welfare is a key element of conducting research involving animals. The aim of this project was to co-create animal welfare monitoring systems that could contribute to best practice husbandry standards of farm animals in a real animal research setting. Researchers worked with nine staff to co-design six bespoke welfare assessment protocols to be conducted in addition to legally required welfare monitoring for adult cattle, calves, sheep, pigs, and goats in specific experimental environments that included both positive and negative welfare elements. Four protocols were subsequently applied with variable frequency by three staff to cattle, goats, and two pig populations. Assessments were all observational and included behavioural and physical condition data. Two staff provided feedback on their views of the process. A key finding was that with facilitation, staff could generate protocols that included elements designed to encourage or evaluate interventions to promote positive emotions. However, data collection was sporadic, and although the staff who provided feedback reported that they valued the process highly, they noted that the primary challenge was finding the time to conduct the additional assessments. We therefore conclude that sustained support is likely to be required to maximise the benefits for the animals and staff of developing and conducting additional voluntary welfare monitoring of farm animals.

The aim of this project was to co-create an animal welfare monitoring system that incorporated both positive and negative welfare measures that would contribute to best practice husbandry standards of farm animals in a real animal research setting. Researchers worked with nine staff to co-design six bespoke welfare assessment protocols to be conducted in addition to legally required welfare monitoring for adult cattle, calves, sheep, pigs, and goats in specific experimental environments. Four protocols were subsequently applied with variable frequency by three staff to cattle, goats, and two pig populations. Assessments were all observational, and included behavioural scan sampling, Qualitative Behaviour Assessment scores, visual analogue mood scores, and physical condition data. Two staff provided feedback on their views of the process. A key finding was that with facilitation, staff could generate protocols that included elements designed to encourage or evaluate interventions to promote positive emotions. However, data collection was sporadic, and although the staff who provided feedback reported that they valued the process highly, they noted that the primary challenge was finding the time to conduct the assessments. We therefore conclude that sustained support is likely to be required to maximise the benefits for the animals and staff of developing and conducting voluntary welfare monitoring of farm animals.