Effects of substituting TV-watching time with physical activities or sleep on incident major depression. Results from the lifelines cohort study

TL;DR

Replacing TV time with physical activities or sleep may help prevent depression in middle-aged adults, but only sports help older adults.

Contribution

This study reveals age-specific benefits of replacing TV time with physical activities or sleep to prevent depression.

Findings

Reallocating TV time to physical activity or sleep reduced depression risk in middle-aged adults.

Only substituting TV with sports reduced depression risk in older adults.

No significant benefit was found for younger adults replacing TV time with other activities.

Abstract

Physical activity is a known protective factor against depression but physical activity competes with other time-consuming behaviors that may increase depression risk. This study investigates the association between time spent in various movement-related activities and incident major depression, with a particular focus on the effects of replacing TV-watching time with other activities. Additionally, we explored whether the impact of substituting TV-watching differs across age groups.

A population-based cohort study (Lifelines) with four-year follow-up, including 65,454 non-depressed adults (18+). Participants self-reported time spent in active commuting, leisure, sports, household, work or school physical-related activities, TV-watching, and sleep. Major depressive disorder was assessed using the Mini International Neuropsychiatric Interview. Compositional isotemporal data analysis was performed to analyze the effect of reallocating time in TV-watching with other activities adjusting for potential confounders. Interactions with age groups were also examined.

The incidence of major depressive disorder was 2.4%. Reallocating TV-watching time to any other physical activity or sleep reduced this risk in middle-aged adults. In older adults, only substituting TV-watching time with sports reduced the probability of becoming depressed. No significant reduction in probabilities for incident depression was found in younger adults.

Replacing TV-watching time with other activities, including sleep, may serve as a preventive strategy against depressive disorder in middle-aged adults, while only the substitution with sports seems beneficial for older adults. Future research should aim to identify other activities, particularly in younger adults, that may prevent depression.

Figures