Assessment of the brain impact of soccer heading using pupillary light reflex

TL;DR

This study uses pupillary light reflex to assess brain impact from soccer heading and finds rubber balls may reduce neurological effects compared to regular balls.

Contribution

First study to evaluate brain impact from soccer heading using pupillary light reflex (PLR) and compare regular and rubber balls.

Findings

Regular soccer balls caused more significant changes in PLR parameters compared to rubber balls.

Constriction rate (CH) and velocity (CV) decreased significantly after repeated headings with regular balls.

Using rubber balls during training may reduce brain impacts from heading.

Abstract

Soccer heading is linked to adverse cognitive effects and changes similar to traumatic brain injury (TBI). In recent years, pupil light reflex (PLR) analysis via pupillometry offers a practical, reliable and objective neurological assessment for TBI. This is the first study to evaluate brain impact from soccer heading by evaluating PLR. We aimed to evaluate changes in PLR from heading and investigate if rubber balls reduce brain impacts compared with regular soccer balls.

Our study involved 30 male healthy volunteer participants aged 18–29 years with >5 years of soccer experience. PLR was measured using the NPi-200 pupillometer system before and after performing every 10 headings, up to 30 headings with regular (session 1) and rubber soccer balls (session 2) in separate sessions. The parameters included neurological pupil index (NPi), constriction rate (CH), constriction velocity (CV), and maximum constriction velocity (MCV).

In session 1, CH and MCV significantly decreased compared with the baseline after 30 headings. In session 2, only CH significantly decreased compared with the baseline. CH significantly decreases from the 20th heading onwards in session 1 compared with session 2 (both at 20 and 30 headings; p < 0.001). CV significantly decreased after the 30th heading in session 1 compared with session 2 (p = 0.038). MCV significantly decreased at the 20th (p = 0.037) and 30th (p = 0.010) headings in session 1 compared with session 2.

Heading affects PLR, with regular soccer balls causing more significant changes than rubber balls. The use of rubber balls during training may mitigate brain impacts, offering a safer alternative for players.

Figures