Evaluation of decision support to wean patients from mechanical ventilation in intensive care: a prospective study reporting clinical and physiological outcomes

TL;DR

A study tested a decision support system for weaning patients off ventilators but found no significant change in ventilation duration, though fewer adverse events were observed.

Contribution

The study evaluated a novel open-loop decision support system for ventilator weaning in ICU patients, revealing potential safety benefits despite no change in ventilation duration.

Findings

No significant difference in duration of mechanical ventilation between the intervention and usual care groups.

Patients in the intervention group had lower rates of adverse events, including fewer hypoxaemic events.

The decision support system's advice was applied in 88% of cases, with changes mainly in inspired oxygen fraction.

Abstract

This study investigated the clinical and physiological response to use of the BEACON Caresystem, a bedside open-loop decision support system providing advice to guide clinicians when weaning patients from invasive mechanical ventilation. Multicenter prospective study conducted in five adult intensive care units in the UK. Following screening and assent, intubated patients mechanically ventilated for > 24 h were randomized to intervention or usual care. Intervention consisted of application of the BEACON Caresystem’s advice on tidal volume/inspiratory pressure, inspired oxygen, respiratory rate and PEEP. Usual care was defined as local clinical practice. The primary outcome was duration of mechanical ventilation. Secondary outcomes quantified prolonged intubation and survival; adverse events; ventilator settings and physiological state; time spent in ventilator modes; links to other therapy; the frequency of advice utilization and time spent outside normal physiological limits. The study was terminated early with a total of 112 patients included. Fifty-four were randomised to the intervention arm and fifty-eight to usual care. The study was underpowered and no significant differences were seen in duration of mechanical ventilation (p = 0.773), prolonged intubation or survival. Intervention arm patients had lower rates of adverse events (p = 0.016), including fewer hypoxaemic events (p = 0.008) and lower values of PEEP (p = 0.030) and tidal volume (p = 0.042). Values of peak inspiratory pressure and pressure support were reduced but at the boarder of statistical significance (p = 0.104, p = 0.093, respectively). No differences were seen for time in ventilator mode or other therapy. Advice presented by the decision support system was applied at the beside an average of 88% of occasions, with a significantly increased number of changes only in inspired oxygen fraction. No significant differences were seen in time spent outside physiological limits. This study investigated the use of the BEACON Caresystem, an open loop clinical decision support system providing advice on ventilator settings. It was terminated early, with no significant difference shown in duration of mechanical ventilation, the primary outcome. Application of advice indicated potential for fewer adverse events and improved physiological status. (Trial registration ClinicalTrials.gov under NCT03249623. Registered 22nd June 2017)

The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1007/s10877-024-01231-5.

Figures