Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis of Transcendental Meditation for Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder

TL;DR

Transcendental Meditation significantly reduces PTSD symptoms more effectively than other meditation techniques and works faster than some therapies.

Contribution

This study provides strong evidence that Transcendental Meditation has a larger effect on PTSD than other meditation types and is non-inferior to established therapies.

Findings

Transcendental Meditation showed a large effect size (g = −1.13) in reducing PTSD symptoms.

TM was non-inferior to prolonged exposure therapy and showed faster results within six weeks.

The pooled effect of TM compared to other treatments was g = −1.01 with high statistical significance.

Abstract

Background and Objectives. Our recent systematic review and meta-analysis of all studies on meditation as treatment for PTSD (61 studies) found a moderate effect size of Hedges’s g = −0.67 for post-minus-pre change in symptom scores. Separate tests of the four meditation categories found a large effect size of g = −1.13 for the Transcendental Meditation (TM) technique that is significantly greater than for each other category. The present follow-up used a different method, calculating effects relative to internal controls, to better characterize the effects of this meditation technique. Materials and Methods. Our study followed Prisma guidelines. Major databases, research anthologies, and bibliographies were searched for studies that used TM for treating PTSD, all military and civilian populations, and all age groups. Results. The searches located 15 controlled trials on TM that met the inclusion criteria (longitudinal and reporting sufficient statistics to calculate effect sizes), 1248 subjects total, mean age 40.5 years (range 20.6 to 54.4 years), and 46.9% males (range 0% to 100%). Using the random effects model, the pooled effect across all studies of TM compared to other treatments was g = −1.01, 95% CI = −1.29 to −0.74, p < 0.000000001. One-study removed analysis found that no study reduced the pooled effect to less than −1.0. Funnel plots indicated no risk of bias. TM was non-inferior to prolonged exposure therapy, p = 0.0001, and it worked significantly faster (p = 0.04 at week six). Conclusions. TM produced clinically meaningful reductions in PTSD for civilian and military personnel, young and older adults, and for both men and women. We recommend phase-III multisite studies comparing TM with known first-line treatments for PTSD.

Figures