Appearances Can Be Deceptive: Morphological, Phylogenetic, and Nomenclatural Delineation of Two Newly Named African Species Related to Frankenia pulverulenta (Frankeniaceae)

TL;DR

This paper describes two new African species of Frankenia, distinct from F. pulverulenta, using morphology and DNA data to correct past misidentifications.

Contribution

The paper introduces two new species, F. sahariensis and F. dinteri, based on integrative taxonomic and molecular evidence.

Findings

Molecular and morphological data show F. sahariensis and F. dinteri are distinct from F. pulverulenta.

Two new names are proposed to replace previously illegitimate species names.

Phylogenetic trees provide the most comprehensive understanding of Frankenia to date.

Abstract

Frankenia is a morphologically complex genus, with some species exhibiting a few diagnostic characters and significant morphological variability. This has led to misidentification or the synonymisation of many names based on one or a few diagnostic traits. This phenomenon affects the annual sea-heath, F. pulverulenta, a Eurasian–Mediterranean herb that has become subcosmopolitan, to which several entities have been included due to their shared features, namely their annual lifespan or their flattened leaves. However, this fact also extends to shrubby species, such as the Madeiran F. cespitosa. Here, integrative taxonomic studies, encompassing detailed morphological descriptions of macro- and microcharacters along with molecular phylogenetic analyses of both nuclear ribosomal (ITS1-5.8S-ITS2 region) and plastid (matK gene) DNA sequence data, and an analysis of biogeographic data were undertaken. This examination has resulted in the most complete phylogenetic trees of Frankenia to date, leading to the reinstatement of two African species broadly differing morphologically from F. pulverulenta. Firstly, F. florida L.Chevall., a name applied to a species occurring in the Saharan regions of Algeria, Morocco, Mali, and Mauritania, is often accepted as a variety or subspecies of the annual sea-heath. In contrast, F. densa Pohnert, a species endemic to southern Namibia and northern South Africa, has been synonymised with F. pulverulenta. However, since those two names were later homonyms of two Chilean and Australian plants, they were deemed illegitimate upon publication. Consequently, two new names are proposed for them: F. sahariensis and F. dinteri, respectively. Their substantiation as independent species is provided by data on their morphology, distribution, ecology, and molecular phylogenetics, which demonstrate their distinctiveness from F. pulverulenta. Nomenclatural synonymy and types are also presented for all concerned names, including the designation of two new lectotypes. Furthermore, the importance of an accurate description of the morphological variation in populations is emphasised for a precise identification of taxa in Frankenia.

Figures