# Risk management during times of health uncertainty in Spain: A qualitative analysis of ethical challenges

## TL;DR

This study explores how experts in Spain manage health risks during uncertain times, focusing on ethical challenges and the need for shared values in decision-making.

## Contribution

The paper introduces a new theoretical framework for ethical risk management based on grounded theory and expert narratives from Spain.

## Key findings

- Experts identified human vulnerability as a central issue in health risk management.
- The study highlights the importance of common ethical paradigms for global health decision-making.
- It emphasizes the need for humanistic training to guide ethical responsibility in uncertain situations.

## Abstract

The study examines the reflections of various experts in risk management when asked about uncertainty generated by a health threat and the response to such a threat: what criteria should guide action when potential harm is anticipated, but not known with certainty? The objective of the research is to obtain a holistic perspective of ethical conflicts in risk management, based on experts’ accounts within the Spanish territory. A qualitative study was conducted through semi‐structured interviews with 27 experts from various fields related to health risk management and its ethical implications, following the grounded theory method. The method includes theory generation through an inductive approach, based on the identified categories. The 27 narratives obtained revealed a variety of fundamental issues grouped into 8 subcategories and subsequently grouped into three main categories. The first category focuses on human vulnerability in health matters. The second category explores the agents and instruments for decision‐making that arise from uncertain or traumatic social events. The third category refers to the need for common ethical paradigms for all humanity that implement justice over universal values. A main theory was suggested on the concept of responsibility in a global common good. There is an urgent need to assume this integrative responsibility as an inherent strategy in decision‐making. To achieve this, the involved actors must acquire specific humanistic training, conceptualizing fundamental ethical principles, and emphasizing skills more related to humanistic virtues than technical knowledge.