Dreaming in Bipolar Disorders – Feasibility of the Central Image Method: A Prospective Controlled Trial

TL;DR

This study shows that the Central Image Method is a reliable way to analyze dreams in people with bipolar disorder and healthy individuals.

Contribution

The study demonstrates the feasibility of using the Central Image Method for analyzing dream emotions in bipolar disorder.

Findings

The Central Image Method showed very good interrater agreement for primary and secondary dream emotions.

Depressed bipolar patients had more negative dream emotions compared to euthymic patients and healthy controls.

Dream emotions may reflect different emotion regulation patterns in bipolar disorder states.

Abstract

Emotions play an important role in the emergence, formation, and experience of dreams. The Central Image (CI) in a dream refers to the dream’s dominant or underlying emotion, and it is the best-remembered part of a dream. Bipolar disorders are characterized by strong emotions, particularly during manic and depressive episodes. In these patients, dreams and CIs may serve as a helpful diagnostic and therapeutic tool. This study aims to evaluate the feasibility of the CI Method and to check for differences concerning dreams and CI emotions between healthy controls and patients with bipolar disorder.

Over a period of 3 weeks, 61 participants were asked to maintain a daily record of all dreams remembered. Dream reports were rated using the Central Image Method (CIM) by two independent, blinded raters. We assessed for interrater agreement on the CIM and for within and between group differences related to negative and positive CI emotions.

Mean agreement rates (weighted Cohen’s kappa) for the CI emotion ratings could be classified as very good: For primary CI emotion ratings, the mean weighted Cohen’s kappa was 0.99 (± 0.02), and for secondary CI emotions, it was 0.90 (± 0.17). Regarding the CI intensities, the mean agreement rate (Spearman’s correlation) was also strong. Evaluation of differences within the groups showed that there were more negative CI emotions than positive CI emotions in healthy controls and currently depressive patients; however, in the latter, the difference was statistically not significant. Analyses of differences between groups indicated that patients who were currently depressed recorded more negative CI emotions in dreams than those who were euthymic or healthy controls.

The findings support the feasibility of the CIM. Our results might indicate different emotion regulation and defense mechanisms across bipolar disorder states, as reflected by the occurrence of negative and positive CI emotions.

Figures