The real-world effectiveness of preschoolers wearing masks on campus to prevent respiratory infectious diseases: a cohort study

TL;DR

A study found that preschoolers wearing masks indoors at school did not significantly reduce respiratory infections.

Contribution

This study evaluates mask effectiveness in preschoolers in a real-world campus setting using a cohort design.

Findings

Indoor mask-wearing did not significantly reduce respiratory infections in preschoolers.

Logistic and Cox regression analyses showed no significant relationship between mask-wearing and infection occurrence.

The study had limitations including small sample size and short observation period.

Abstract

Respiratory infections are common in the pediatric population. Preschoolers, especially those in kindergarten and 3–6 years old, are highly vulnerable to various respiratory infections.

To investigate the efficacy of indoor mask-wearing in mitigating respiratory infections in preschoolers in a real-world campus setting.

The study was conducted over a 115-day period in a kindergarten. Eligible children were assigned into study and control groups. The study group wore masks indoors but not outdoors, and the control group did not wear masks in either setting. We used a questionnaire to collect participant information, including age, height, weight, monthly dietary living expenses, family annual income, parent education level, primary caregiver, number of family members, and number of children under 6 years of age in the household. Incidences of clinical respiratory infections were recorded. We calculated the relative risk and analyzed the relationship between mask-wearing and respiratory infections by inter-group comparison, logistic regression, and Cox regression analyses.

A total of 135 preschoolers were included, with 35 and 100 preschoolers in the study and control groups, respectively. Baseline comparisons showed a significant difference in the number of children under 6 years old in the household between the two groups. Mask-wearing did not significantly reduce the risk of respiratory infections (RR = 1.086, 95% CI: 0.713, 1.435). Logistic and Cox regression analyses also showed no significant relationship between mask-wearing and occurrence of respiratory infections after controlling for potential confounders (OR = 0.816, 95% CI: 0.364, 1.826, and HR = 0.845, 95% CI: 0.495, 1.444).

Indoor mask-wearing did not reduce the incidence of respiratory infections in preschoolers in a real-world campus setting. However, this study included a small number of preschoolers and observed them for a short period of time. Preschoolers were instructed to wear masks only when indoors. These factors could lead to bias and limit the generalizability of the study results.

Figures