Pneumococcal infective endocarditis in Brazil: a multicenter study on a severe condition

TL;DR

This study examines pneumococcal infective endocarditis in Brazil, highlighting its severity and high mortality rate despite antibiotic treatment.

Contribution

The study provides new insights into the clinical characteristics and outcomes of pneumococcal infective endocarditis in Brazil.

Findings

Pneumococcal infective endocarditis was identified in 0.47% of IE cases, with a high mortality rate of 6/11.

Surgical intervention was indicated for all patients, but only 6 underwent surgery, with better outcomes in those who did.

The study emphasizes the importance of prompt diagnosis and vaccination for at-risk patients.

Abstract

Streptococcus pneumoniae bacteremia may result in Infective Endocarditis (IE). In the pre-antibiotic era, it caused 10 %‒15 % of IE, decreasing to < 3 % after penicillin availability. Although infrequent, it causes aggressive disease.

Retrospective analysis of endocarditis databases, prospectively implemented in 4 Brazilian institutions, 2005‒2023.

From the prospective cohorts comprising 2321 adult patients with IE, we identified 11 (0.47%) with pneumococcal IE. Males represented 7/11 and mean age was 54 years (22‒77). All had native valve involvement; perivalvular abscess was present in 6/11. Only one patient had concurrent meningitis. Beta-lactams were the antibiotics used in 10/11. All had surgical indication, but only 6 had it, as the others were seriously ill. Overall, in hospital mortality was 6/11, but only 1/6 of those who underwent surgery died, compared to 5/5 of those who had an indication for surgery and did not have it.

The high mortality rates and need for surgical intervention emphasize the need to promptly identify and manage pneumococcal endocarditis. Physicians ought to recommend vaccination to all patients at risk for severe pneumococcal disease.

Full text

Streptococcus pneumoniae is a Gram-positive encapsulated coccus which belongs to the normal microbiota of the upper respiratory tract.1^,^2 It is the leading etiologic agent of community-acquired pneumonia, meningitis, sinusitis, and otitis media. When it causes bacteremia, secondary complications such as endocarditis, arthritis, or meningitis may occur.3^,^4

Invasive Pneumococcal Disease (IPD) is an infection confirmed by isolating S. pneumoniae from sterile sites. It remains a frequent condition in adults in some predisposed groups, especially elderly patients, those with diabetes, cirrhosis, chronic renal failure, splenectomy, or functional asplenia, and HIV positive patients.3, 4, 5, 6 Despite this, infective endocarditis rarely results from pneumococcal bacteremia. Marrie et al., in Canada, evaluated 3251 adult patients with IPD and verified that only 28 (0.3 %) developed endocarditis; 7 these patients were more likely to use illicit drugs and have a higher severity of illness at presentation (higher rate of altered mental status and need for intensive care), and higher mortality (39.3% vs. 14.7 % respectively). 7 However, no other major risk factors were identified for endocarditis in adults with IPD.7 In a prospective, international, observational study, eight of 844 patients hospitalized with S. pneumoniae bacteraemia only 5 developed IE (0.6 %).8 They did not show greater mortality (1/5 or 20 % with IE died) or a different clinical pattern, and the bacterial isolates from the endocarditis cases showed no specific virulence traits or adherence capabilities.8 In a study on IPD in Israel,9 from 2009‒2019, 23/4119 (0.6 %) were endovascular pneumococcal infections; inhospital mortality was 21.7 %.9 In Australia, a retrospective study on pneumococcal bacteremia in adults10 included from 2011–2020 found that only 2/300 (0.7 %) were endocarditis cases.10 In Brazil, a recent study on IPD in HIV positive patients in a infectious diseases referral center in Brazil, from 2005‒2020, showed that none of the 55 patients had IE.5

From a historical perspective, S. pneumoniae used to frequently cause acute endocarditis in the pre antibiotic era,11 but the main causative germ shifted to S.aureus post the availability of penicillins in medical practice; moreover, since penicillin became available, the frequency of pneumococcal endocarditis decreased from 10 %–15 % to < 3 %.12 Indeed, contemporary studies from laboratories which have dealt with streptococcal bacteremia and correlated these infections to endocarditis diagnosis, have reported different weights to the diverse streptococcal species and have found S. pneumoniae as non-associated to IE.13^,^14 This has led to S.pneumoniae being excluded from the typical viridans group as major criterion in the Duke-ISCVID criteria update in 2023. However, although pneumococcal IE is relatively uncommon, it is a severe disease, with inhospital mortality rates that vary from 20.7 % to 39.3 %.7^,^9^,^15^,^16 Furthermore, it may occur in all age groups, and may be associated with another severe infection, meningitis.17^,^18

No Brazilian series of pneumococcal IE has been published so far. We have, therefore, set out to study pneumococcal endocarditis at 4 sites in Brazil, to estimate its relative frequency, characteristics and outcomes.

This was a retrospective analysis of endocarditis databases, prospectively implemented, with a post hoc study driven by analysis of cases of pneumococcal endocarditis. Consecutive and prospective adult patients with definite endocarditis according to the modified Duke criteria were studied from 2005 to 2023 in 4 Brazilian institutions, all public hospitals, two of which were cardiac referral centers, and two university hospitals. Centers participating in this study were Instituto Nacional de Cardiologia (INC), Hospital Universitário Clementino Fraga Filho, from the Federal University of Rio de Janeiro (UFRJ), Hospital Universitário Pedro Ernesto (HUPE/UERJ), all located in Rio de Janeiro city, and Instituto do Coração (InCor), part of the University Hospital of São Paulo, located in the city of São Paulo. This is, therefore, a convenience sample. The study was approved by each local Ethics Committee.

Clinical and laboratory data were collected from patients’ notes. Microbiological data were collected from the results provided by the Bacteriology Laboratories in an automated system and from internal laboratory records of each institution. Isolation of Streptococcus pneumoniae by direct inoculation of clinical samples (blood) onto enriched culture media (chocolate agar and blood agar) and incubation at 5 % CO_2_ and 35±1 °C temperature, within 72 hours of receiving the samples, previously inoculated into automated culture flasks (Bactec/Becton Dickson) for up to 5 days. Antimicrobial susceptibility testing was carried out using the agar diffusion method (disc diffusion), and determination of the minimum inhibitory concentration by agar diffusion with a gradient strip. The interpretative criteria of the CLSI ‒ Clinical and Laboratory Standards Institute were followed. Molecular tests and serotyping were not routinely done.

Study variables: The study variables were obtained from each cohort's database and supplemented with data extracted from the electronic medical records. The following variables were collected: sex at birth, age at diagnosis, valve affected, presence of perivalvular abscess, vegetation size, embolization to the central nervous system or spleen, antibiotics used, duration of treatment, whether surgery was indicated, creatinine levels on admission, days of hospitalization and in hospital death outcome. The only variable obtained retrospectively was the Euroscore on admission.

Descriptive statistical analysis (frequencies) and mean, standard deviation and amplitude statistics were performed using the Microsoft Excel software.

From the prospective cohorts comprising 2321 adult patients with infective endocarditis, we identified eleven with Pneumococcal Endocarditis (PE) from 2005 to 2023, from the afore mentioned Brazilian institutions. In institution A, the frequency of PE in adults was of 7/1154 (0.6 %) of cases, in institution B, of 2/502 (0.4 %), in institution C 1/539 (0.2 %) and in institution D, 1/126 (0.7 %); mean frequency was therefore of 11/2321 (0.5 %). Clinical and laboratory aspects of the cases are shown on Table 1.Table 1. Cases of pneumococcal endocarditis in four Brazilian medical centers, 2005‒2023.Table 1. CasesYear/ SiteGenderAge (years)Affected valvesPerivalvular abscessLargest vegetation size (in mm)Antibiotics usedTotal duration of treatment (days)Was surgery indicated?Was surgery done?Serum Creatinine (mg/dL)Euro SCORE IILength of hospitalization (days)Inhospital death?12005 AFemale51Native AVNo****NAVancomycin + gentamicin + ceftriaxone30YesYes0.70.86 %30No22007 CMale22Native MVYes20 mmPenicillin + gentamicin + ampicillin79YesYes0.81.7 %52No32007 BMale51Native AV and MVYes25 mmPenicillin + gentamicin41YesYes0.83.21 %46No42008 AMale75Native AVNo13 mmPenicillin + gentamicin11YesNoa2.138.61 %11Yes52008 AFemale55Native TVNo7mmVancomycin27YesNoa2.231.31 %27Yes62011 AFemale77Native AV and MVNoNACeftriaxone + gentamicin12YesYes1.821.18 %12Yes72011 BMale31Native AVYesNIAmpicilin + gentamicin42YesYes1.11.24 %55No82016 AMale39Native AV and MVNo4 mmCeftriaxone + clarithromycin + oxacillin37YesYes0.78.2 %37No92016 AMale65Native AVYes14 mmCeftriaxoneNIYesNoa1.3510.78 %17Yes102017 DFemale64Native MVYesNIVancomycin + ceftriaxone6YesNoa1.4824.72 %6Yes112022 AMale71Native AV and MVYes> 10 mmCeftriaxone4YesNoa3.1718.67 %4YesInstitutions A, B, C and D to be disclosed after review.bNA, Not Available; mm, Milimetres; AV, Aortic Valve; MV, Mitral Valve; TV, Tricuspid Valve.aSeriously ill or critically ill.bInstitutions A,B,C and D are A=INCOR=Instituto do Coração, Universidade de São Paulo; B= INC=Instituto Nacional de Cardiologia, Rio de JaneiroC=UFRJ=Universidade Federal do Rio de Janeiro; D= HUPE/UERJ=Hospital Universitario Pedro Ernesto, Universidade do Estado do Rio de Janeiro

The majority, 7/11 were male, with a mean age of 54 years (range 22‒77). Only one patient was splenectomized. All had native valve left-sided native valve IE, except for one, who had native tricuspid valve involvement. None had previous valvular disease. Perivalvular abscess was present in 6/11. The size of the vegetation was measured in 7 out of 11 patients (for 2 patients the information was not available, and 2 did not present vegetations) with an average of 13 mm (4‒25). Only one of the patients presented embolization to the central nervous system, and none presented emboli to the spleen, or vertebrae.

Beta lactams were the antibiotics used in 10/11 patients, and 1 patient used vancomycin; gentamicin was associated in 6 patients. Mean duration of antibiotic therapy was 29 days (4‒79) in 10/11 (in one patient duration of therapy was not available, and two patients died quickly, at 4 and 6 days of hospitalization). All patients had surgery indicated, but only six patients effectively underwent surgery, as 5/11 were not clinically well enough to be operated. Euroscore II, as a percent chance of post operative death, was calculated for all patients and presented in Table 1. Average length of stay was 27 days (4‒55), and 6 out of 11 died; only one patient of the 6 who were operated died, vs. 5 of the 5 of those who had an indication for surgery and did not have it.

Our multicenter study is the first to describe pneumococcal endocarditis in Brazil. Similarly to what has been reported in contemporary series, from Canada,7 Israel,9 Australia10 and European countries,9^,^15, 16, 17, 18 we found that pneumococcal IE was infrequent . However, it was associated with a severe status, destructive disease, and death in over half our patients (6/11); all five patients who had indication to operate, but were too poorly to have surgery, died. Daudin et al.19 found patients with pneumococcal IE, compared to those with other causes of IE, had more heart failure (64.3% vs. 23.2 %; p < 0.01), shock (53.6% vs. 23.2 %; p < 0.01), need for cardiac surgery (64.3 %) but an inhospital mortality rate of 7.1 %, with surgery having a protective effect.19 We emphasize that all but one of our patients who had surgery died.

Only 4 of our 11 patients were elderly and only one presented comorbidities which involved immunosupression (splenectomy); none had diabetes, HIV, cancer, or use of immunossupressive drugs. As a matter of fact, a case-control study, comparing 28 patients with pneumococcal IE with those with other causes of IE (paired only by order of hospital admission) in a teaching center in France,19 found some differences between groups: in pneumococcal IE patients, there was a higher proportion of alcoholism (39.3% vs. 10.7 %; p < 0.01) and smoking (60.7% vs. 21.4 %; p < 0.01). Another older French study found that half of the 30 patients with IE suffered from chronic alcoholism.15 A study on 111 cases of pneumococcal IE16 comprising 24 patients from the Spanish cohort (2004 to 2013) and 87 cases from literature review (2000‒2013), showed liver disease was present in 27.9 %, immunosuppression in 10.8 % and splenectomy or asplenia in 8.1 %.16 We have no information on alcohol and smoking in our patients, but 4 of 11 were young and previously healthy. Only one of our patients (Case 9) had had previous splenectomy (as a child), and none of the others had liver disease or immunosupression.

All our patients had pneumococcal IE on native valves but abscesses were frequent, occuring in 6/11; in Egea et al.,16 abscesses were found in only 8.1 % of the 111 patients, and in 7/30 (23.3 %) patients in Lefort et al.15 This may be due to a referral bias, as two of our centers were reference for cardiac surgery.

Only one of the patients in our series had meningitis (Case 9, who actually had the Austrian syndrome), differently from others.15, 16, 17, 18 This may be because the association is rare (< 5 %) and we have only 11 patients in our series. An older series, with 30 adult patients reviewed retrospectively between 1991 and 1998 in France, found that 12 (40 %) had associated meningitis.15 Meningitis concomitant with endocarditis was described as a risk factor associated with death on multivariate analysis with an OR, of 4.3; in this study, meningitis was present in 40.5 % of the 111 patients,16 and Austrian syndrome in 26.1 % of them.16 Other recent series have dealt with this association. A prospective nationwide observational cohort study on patients with community-acquired bacterial meningitis in the Netherlands from 2006 to 2012 identified endocarditis in 24 of 1025 episodes (2 %); S.pneumoniae accounted for 13 of those (54.2 %).17 Another study looked at the association of IE and meningitis: it was conducted in France, where 2 databases, one from 2008 with patients with IE in seven French regions, and the other with community-acquired acute bacterial meningitis, from 69 French hospitals in 2013–2014, were matched.18 Among the 1030 patients from the merged cohorts, there were 42 (4.1 %) patients who had both IE and meningitis; of these, 18 (42.9 %) had S.pneumoniae as the causative microorganism and 7 (16.7 %) patients with IE and bacterial meningitis presented an Austrian syndrome.18 All patients with S.pneumoniae IE and meningitis were at risk for invasive pneumococcal disease (alcoholism, smoking, diabetes mellitus and AIDS in varying proportions), and had a severe presentation (septic shock, heart failure, or coma), but, surprisingly, none died.18

Although pneumococcal vaccination is crucial in elderly patients and those with comorbidities, in our small series, 7 of our cases had no formal indication for it and for the other four, vaccination status was not recorded. Only one of our patients had the pneumococcal serogroup determined (it was the 22F).20 We found only one study on pneumococcal serogroups in endovascular infections (including IE) involving a fair amount of patients; in this Israeli study, 18/23 had their vaccine status known but only 4 (22.2 %) received the vaccine prior to their pneumococcal endovascular infection.9 All medical specialties must reinforce the need to vaccinate susceptible patients, as pneumococcal endocarditis is rare, but pneumococcal pneumonia is a very common condition, of potential severity.3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10^,^15^,^16

Limitations of our study are that results may not be generalizable, as the endocarditis cohorts from which patients with pneumococcal endocarditis were described are followed up in referral centers, either surgical or university hospitals. Besides, the sample is a convenience sample and the number of pneumococcal endocarditis is very small, making strong assumptions unfeasible.

In conclusion, although pneumococcal IE is rare, it should be sought for in patients with severe pneumococcal infections, especially if heart murmur and emboli are identified. The relativelly high mortality and need for surgical intervention emphasize the need to promptly identify and manage pneumococcal endocarditis. Lastly, physicians ought to recommend vaccination to all patients at risk for severe pneumococcal disease.

Conflicts of interest

The authors declare no conflicts of interest.