Outcomes after 4 years’ experience with low suction drains. Would it be safe to go drainless or low suction?

TL;DR

This study compares omitting chest drains or using low suction drains after thoracic surgery and finds both safe and beneficial for recovery.

Contribution

Demonstrates safety of drainless or low suction drain approaches in thoracic surgery when visceral pleura is intact.

Findings

Omitting drains or using low suction drains safely replaces traditional one-way valves.

Drainless or low suction drain strategies are linked to shorter hospital stays.

Early patient mobilization is encouraged with these approaches.

Abstract

The principles of chest drainage have not changed significantly since 1875 when Bülau introduced the idea of underwater drainage tube which became a trademark of thoracic surgery. We performed a prospective, randomized trial comparing omitting pleural drain (drainless group) versus drainage with small low suction drain (drainage group) strategies of thoracic surgery when the visceral pleura remains intact. Aiming to investigate whether these approaches represent safe treatment options.

A multi-center, prospective, parallel group, randomized, controlled trial enrolling patients after thoracic procedures in which visceral pleura remained intact at the end of surgery between August 2020 and September 2023. After completion of the procedure a suction-seal test was conducted on all patients. If suction-seal test was positive to confirm absence of air leak, patients were randomized to either receive low auto-suction drain as a solo pleural drain (drainage group) or not to receive drain (drainless group).

During the study period, 111 patients were recruited. Eleven patients had negative Suction-seal test and were excluded by inserting a traditional underwater seal. The remaining 100 patients were randomly assigned to either drainage group with low suction drain (Fig. 1) (n = 50) or drainless group (n = 50).

The results of this study suggest that either omitting drain or inserting a low auto suction drain safely substitutes the one-way valve when the visceral pleura remains intact. Omitting drain or inserting portable small caliber drain encourages early mobilization and is associated with shorter hospital stay.

Figures