# The shadow of fear: hate crime victimization and stress after Charlottesville

## TL;DR

The paper examines how a high-profile hate crime in Charlottesville increased stress among African-Americans but not other minority groups.

## Contribution

It introduces a novel method using a natural experiment to assess the causal impact of hate crimes on stress in specific communities.

## Key findings

- Anti-Black hate crimes increased in the two weeks after the Charlottesville event.
- African-Americans reported higher stress due to perceived vulnerability to hate crimes.
- Hispanics and Asian Americans did not show significant stress increases following the event.

## Abstract

Recent years have witnessed an increase in highly publicized attacks targeting members of ethnoracial and religious minority groups. To date, existing research has primarily focused on the tendency for such “trigger events” to generate violent aftershocks. We argue that beyond such ripple effects, highly salient trigger events significantly increase hate-crime related stress among racial and ethnic minorities. Additionally, we explore whether these effects are limited to the group most clearly targeted, or if they “spill over” to other minoritized communities.

To study reactions to hate crimes, we draw upon national survey data (N = 1,122) in combination with a natural experiment involving the Unite the Right rally and vehicle attack in Charlottesville, Virginia in August 2017. We employ an “unexpected event during survey” design to estimate the causal effect of the Charlottesville rally on stress about hate crimes.

We first show that there was an increase in anti-Black hate crimes in the 2 weeks following the Charlottesville incident. We also find a corresponding increase in stress due to the perception of personal vulnerability to hate crimes among African-Americans. However, we do not observe a significant increase in levels of stress following the trigger event among Hispanics and Asian Americans.

Our results suggest that highly publicized instances of intergroup violence can have significant impacts on stress about hate crime victimization within the target group. However, we find that this effect is short-lived, and that both violent aftershocks and the general climate of fear spurred by hate crimes may be racially bounded.