# Accuracy of Clinical Suspicion for Rotator Cuff Tears by Orthopedic Surgeons When MRI Was Ordered on Initial Visits: Should Physical Therapy Be Mandated by Insurance Before MRI?

## TL;DR

This study finds that requiring physical therapy before MRI for shoulder pain may delay treatment and increase costs when rotator cuff tears are likely.

## Contribution

The study provides evidence that clinical suspicion for rotator cuff tears by orthopedic surgeons is accurate and that mandated physical therapy may be unnecessary.

## Key findings

- 43.0% of patients had full-thickness rotator cuff tears, 24.7% had partial tears, and 32.2% had no tears.
- 67.2% of MRI orders revealed a rotator cuff tear even without a history of conservative treatment.
- The cost of six weeks of physical therapy is nearly equal to the cost of an MRI.

## Abstract

Introduction: Insurance companies often mandate six weeks of physical therapy (PT) prior to approving MRIs for patients with atraumatic rotator cuff (RTC) tears. While this is designed to limit unnecessary imaging orders, it can increase healthcare costs and delay diagnosis and surgery. This study investigated the incidence of full- and partial-thickness tears when an MRI was ordered at the time of initial consultation for shoulder pain by an orthopedic provider.

Methods: A retrospective review of patients who had an MRI ordered upon initial orthopedic consultation for chronic shoulder pain was conducted. The primary outcome measured was the presence of RTC tears as determined by the MRI report. The cost of six weeks of PT versus the cost of immediate MRI in these patients was collected from our institution’s financial database. ANOVA, independent T-test, and chi-square test were used to analyze the differences between groups.

Results: A total of 365 patients were included. There were no significant differences in demographics between patients with full, partial, or no tears, with the exception that patients with full-thickness tears were older. Specifically, 43.0% had a full-thickness tear, 24.7% had a partial-thickness tear, and 32.2% had no tear on MRI. A total of 56.1% of the full-thickness tears proceeded to surgery. The cost of an upper extremity MRI without contrast averages $2,268, while two sessions of PT per week for six weeks totals $2,328.

Discussion: Over 67% of MRI orders yielded a positive finding of an RTC tear and remained at 67.2% in the absence of a history of conservative treatment, validating a specialist's clinical suspicion for an RTC tear and indication for MRI. Pre-MRI PT to satisfy insurance requirements may therefore delay intervention and increase healthcare costs when an orthopedic provider believes an MRI is warranted for clinical decision-making.