The effects of the COVID-19 pandemic on Italian primary school children’s learning: A systematic review through a psycho-social lens

TL;DR

This paper reviews how the pandemic affected Italian primary school children's learning and emotional well-being, highlighting challenges in distance learning and shared concerns among parents and teachers.

Contribution

The study provides a systematic review of the psychosocial effects of school closures on Italian primary school students, focusing on stakeholder perspectives and learning deficits.

Findings

Distance learning was seen as ineffective by parents and teachers, with technical difficulties reported.

Students showed learning deficits, especially in mathematics, as confirmed by INVALSI results.

The pandemic worsened emotional and academic challenges for students at risk of marginalization.

Abstract

The COVID-19 pandemic drastically affected many areas and contexts of today’s society, including school and family. Several studies focused on the worldwide effects of school closures on students’ learning outcomes, context, and well-being. However, the data emerging from these studies are often inconsistent and fragmentary, highlighting the need of a comprehensive analysis of the phenomenon. This need is especially urgent for the countries with the most severe school closure, like Italy. This systematic review aims to collect the opinions of parents, teachers, and students on: other dimensions of Italian primary school students affected by school closures, beyond academic performance; hypothetical agreement between the opinions of parents, teachers, and students regarding the different effects of school closures on Italian primary school students; possible differences between the effects of school closures on Italian primary school students and the students in other countries. Our search was conducted using PRISMA 2020 guidelines on Web of Science, Pubmed, Scopus, and EBSCOHost. The results obtained from 34 articles revealed a strong concern on the part of all stakeholders involved in learning during the pandemic, with evident negative effects for Italian school students. The constraint on distance learning led to a drastic change in everyone’s routine, and a negative emotional change on the part of young students. Parents and teachers generally considered distance learning to be ineffective for the education of their children and students; they encountered technical-practical difficulties in the use of electronic devices for participation in school activities; overall learning deficits on the part of students, especially in mathematics, as confirmed by INVALSI results were also found. The investigation reveals a condition of shared emotional and academic performance difficulty, and a further challenging circumstance for students previously at risk of marginalization. Further research in this field is paramount to identify new and adequate recovery strategies.

Figures